Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show

Megan Faringa, football journalist and match reporter, breaks down Manchester United Women’s recent struggles. She digs into defensive naivety in the Champions League, the 3-0 derby loss to City, and how injuries and budget limits shape the team. Short, sharp takes on tactics, attendance and what the club must change next.

Andy Mitten, long-time United writer who explains contract and financial context. Carl Anka, journalist with sharp transfer and squad analysis. Laurie Whitwell, experienced reporter offering tactical and transfer insight. They debate Zirkzee’s future, potential departures, whether an experienced striker is needed, internal options like Mbuemo, youth integration and how sales might fund summer business.

Andy Mitten, veteran United columnist and author; Carl Anka, tactical and recruitment analyst; Laurie Whitwell, inside-club reporter. They debate centre-back depth, De Ligt’s fitness and Maguire’s short-term role. They dig into left-back urgency after Malacia’s likely exit, profiles of ideal full-backs, academy defensive prospects, and goalkeeper succession questions.

Andy Mitten, longtime Manchester United journalist with inside-club reporting; Carl Anka, tactical writer with historical context; Laurie Whitwell, detailed transfers and tactics analyst. They debate midfield priorities for a 60-game season. Shortlists of potential signings are discussed. The urgent need for a defensive six, rotation plans, and how contracts, wages and rival interest shape recruitment are explored.

Andy Mitten, long‑time Manchester United writer offering tactical insight, and Carl Anka, experienced match analyst and reporter, dissect a dramatic Bournemouth draw. They debate contentious refereeing decisions and Harry Maguire’s red card. They praise Bruno Fernandes and Matheus Cunha, consider squad rotation and contract talks for Mainoo and Maguire, and preview England call-ups and World Cup audition stakes.

Chris McKenna, a feature writer who covers United’s youth and Irish travelling support, joins to discuss the FA Youth Cup tie and standout academy prospects. They also preview the Bournemouth trip, debating defensive selections, right-back choices and whether Benjamin Sesko should start or be a super-sub. Plus a look at how fixture changes affect Irish fans heading to Old Trafford.

Andy Mitten, veteran United writer and fanzine editor; Carl Anka, tactical analyst; Mark Critchley, match reporter. They dissect Bruno Fernandes' inspirational impact and record-breaking creativity. They break down set-piece strategies, Casemiro’s headed opener, second-half attacking variety and Carrick’s problem-solving charge. They also touch on transfer dilemmas and the women’s League Cup loss.

Megan Faringa, women's football journalist and tactical analyst, and Chris Weatherspoon, financial reporter and club accounts specialist, discuss Manchester United's crunch fixtures and finances. They talk Villa's threat and tactical selection dilemmas. They cover Old Trafford rebuilding, stadium financing and transfer cashflow. They also preview United women's League Cup final and key players to watch.

Mark Critchley, sharp United reporter and academy watcher; Andy Mitten, long-time club analyst on finance and strategy; Carl Anka, seasoned United commentator on transfers and management. They debate Michael Carrick’s interim run and whether he could be made permanent. Ticket price rises and fan fallout are unpacked. New academy hires and scouting plans conclude the conversation.

They dissect why a promising unbeaten streak ended in a lacklustre defeat at Newcastle. Conversation focuses on left‑side and midfield frailties, struggles to exploit a 10‑man advantage, and Bruno carrying the creative load. Squad construction, summer recruitment needs and late-game errors are debated. The panel also weighs tactical substitutions and whether momentum can be rebuilt.