Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show Do Man United need to fix their defence this summer?
9 snips
Mar 25, 2026 
Andy Mitten, veteran United columnist and author; Carl Anka, tactical and recruitment analyst; Laurie Whitwell, inside-club reporter. They debate centre-back depth, De Ligt’s fitness and Maguire’s short-term role. They dig into left-back urgency after Malacia’s likely exit, profiles of ideal full-backs, academy defensive prospects, and goalkeeper succession questions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Centre Back Depth From Back Three Reliance
- United are overstocked at centre-back because purchases for a back three left them with more than enough for a back four.
- Laurie emphasised Lenny Yoro, Aidan O'Neill and injured De Ligt/Martínez create depth but also uncertainty due to injuries and youth development.
Club Wants A Defensive Leader Not Big Signings
- Manchester United value a defensive leader but won't necessarily spend big on a new centre-half this summer.
- Andy Mitten argued Maguire provides short-term stability while De Ligt and Martínez's injuries create longer-term risk.
Recruit A Left Back As Luke Shaw's Successor
- Sign a left-back to succeed Luke Shaw because Shaw's best attacking days are waning despite value when fit.
- Carl Anka recommended a 1A/1B plan so Shaw can be rotated and phased out responsibly.