The Thomistic Institute

Newman on the Dangers of Liberal Education – Prof. Thomas Hibbs

May 5, 2026
Thomas Hibbs, Baylor philosopher and former dean with books on Aquinas, theology, and film. He traces Newman’s critique of instrumental and careerist education. He explores the integrative philosophical habit, dangers of intellectual pride, the tension between university breadth and collegiate formation, and how Newman’s conscience-based approach complements Aquinas’s natural theology.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Mortimer Adler As Secular Thomist Influence

  • Mortimer Adler influenced mid-20th-century liberal education and bridged secular and Thomistic currents.
  • Hibbs recounts Adler's path: Columbia, Chicago, St. John's, longtime engagement with Aquinas, and late-life conversion to Catholicism.
INSIGHT

University Education Is Pursuit Of Truth

  • A university education aims at pursuing truth in its complexity and unity rather than merely accumulating facts.
  • Thomas Hibbs cites Newman: cultivate enlargement of mind and the philosophical habit of comparing, organizing, and integrating across disciplines.
INSIGHT

Knowledge Does Not Produce Virtue

  • Newman separates intellectual training from moral virtue and warns knowledge alone does not make one good.
  • Hibbs highlights Newman's granite vs razor image: reason cannot contend alone against passions and pride without moral struggle and formation.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app