
Science Fictions Paid-only episode 27: Antidepressants
Feb 24, 2026
A lively critique of Johan Hari’s claims about depression and treatment methods. A breakdown of public controversies and journalistic methods behind sweeping arguments. A focus on conflicting research and dueling meta-analyses about antidepressant effectiveness. A teaser that invites listeners to explore the full debate and evidence in the paid version.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Johan Hari's Lost Connections Sparked Public Fury
- Tom Chivers and Stuart Ritchie recount Johan Hari's book Lost Connections sparking a public row about antidepressants and social causes of depression.
- They describe Hari's globe-trotting narrative and the memorable claim about 'giving people a cow' from a Cambodian study.
Implication Beats Assertion In Shaping Public Views
- Tom and Stuart note Hari doesn't flatly deny antidepressants work but strongly implies they are the wrong solution and overprescribed.
- Stuart highlights Hari's rhetorical style of implying conclusions without explicitly stating them, shaping public perception.
Celebrities Amplified Hari Despite Method Flaws
- Tom recounts public reactions from celebrities like James Corden and politicians who amplified Hari's claims in 2018.
- Stuart and Tom contrast Hari's popularity and success with their view of his methodological failings.





