Science Fictions

Paid-only episode 27: Antidepressants

Feb 24, 2026
A lively critique of Johan Hari’s claims about depression and treatment methods. A breakdown of public controversies and journalistic methods behind sweeping arguments. A focus on conflicting research and dueling meta-analyses about antidepressant effectiveness. A teaser that invites listeners to explore the full debate and evidence in the paid version.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Johan Hari's Lost Connections Sparked Public Fury

  • Tom Chivers and Stuart Ritchie recount Johan Hari's book Lost Connections sparking a public row about antidepressants and social causes of depression.
  • They describe Hari's globe-trotting narrative and the memorable claim about 'giving people a cow' from a Cambodian study.
INSIGHT

Implication Beats Assertion In Shaping Public Views

  • Tom and Stuart note Hari doesn't flatly deny antidepressants work but strongly implies they are the wrong solution and overprescribed.
  • Stuart highlights Hari's rhetorical style of implying conclusions without explicitly stating them, shaping public perception.
ANECDOTE

Celebrities Amplified Hari Despite Method Flaws

  • Tom recounts public reactions from celebrities like James Corden and politicians who amplified Hari's claims in 2018.
  • Stuart and Tom contrast Hari's popularity and success with their view of his methodological failings.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app