
The Left Hand of Le Guin Podcast 10. Discussion of 'The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction'
Sep 11, 2022
David Naimon, Portland-based writer and Le Guin scholar, and Susan DeFreitas, novelist and editor, explore Le Guin's 'Carrier Bag Theory.' They contrast container narratives with heroic arcs. They discuss Always Coming Home, polyvocal storytelling, diminishing conflict, narrative shapes like spirals, and why markets resist nontraditional forms.
00:00
Le Guin's Formal Shift Began With A Crisis
- Le Guin's carrier-bag essay grew from a personal crisis about writing male-centered protagonists.
- Between 1977 and the 1990s she experimented with and revised narrative forms to decenter the heroic individual.
Story As A Carrier Bag Not A Spear
- Ursula K. Le Guin reframes story as a container rather than a spear-shaped climax engine.
- The carrier-bag story holds multiple voices and relations, privileging gathering, meaning, and what readers carry away.
Earthsea Shows Form Evolving Across Books
- The Earthsea cycle shows Le Guin revising earlier heroic forms across books: Ged's arc becomes internal while later books limit external movement.
- Tombs of Atuan tightens scope and centers a young female protagonist's inward struggle.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right 15 chevron_right 16 chevron_right 17 chevron_right 18 chevron_right 19 chevron_right 20 chevron_right 21 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 2min
Why Discuss The Carrier Bag Theory
02:23 • 5min
Context: Le Guin's 1977 Crisis and New Forms
07:01 • 4min
Reading the Essay's Opening Passage
10:42 • 2min
Carrier Bag vs. Hero's Journey
12:31 • 3min
Form's Influence on Style and Character
15:57 • 38sec
Always Coming Home as Carrier Bag Example
16:35 • 1min
Resistance to Nontraditional Forms
17:55 • 3min
Polyvocality and Diminishing Conflict
20:54 • 6min
Earthsea: Evolving From Hero to Community
26:52 • 11min
What Writers Learn from Le Guin's Methods
37:35 • 4min
Tension Versus Conflict as Story Engine
41:39 • 3min
Examples: Voices and Anti-Climactic Climax
44:54 • 2min
Le Guin's Voice and Humor
47:17 • 2min
Subverting History and Gender Narratives
49:37 • 5min
Experimental Forms That Still Engage
54:12 • 10min
Always Coming Home: Past-Future Spiral
01:03:49 • 8min
Narrative Shapes: Spiral, Circle, and Nonlinear Time
01:11:48 • 2min
Modern Works Echoing the Carrier Bag
01:13:19 • 5min
Physical Forms and Publishing Limits
01:18:28 • 4min
Outro
01:22:08 • 7sec
#
Dancing at the Edge of the World
Thoughts on Words, Women, Places


Ursula K. Le Guin
Dancing at the Edge of the World is a 1989 essay collection by Ursula K. Le Guin that gathers her reflections on literature, feminism, language, and society.
The essays range from craft-focused pieces about fiction and storytelling to broader cultural critiques, illustrating Le Guin's humanistic and anthropological sensibilities.
Many pieces investigate the role of gender and power in narrative forms and question received norms of storytelling.
The collection includes the influential essay 'The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction', which reimagines narrative structure as a container rather than a spear-driven heroic arc.
Le Guin's clear prose, wit, and philosophical depth make the volume valuable to writers and readers interested in the politics and possibilities of fiction.

#2146
• Mentioned in 21 episodes
The Book of Joy
Lasting Happiness in a Changing World


Desmond Tutu


Dalai Lama
In this book, the Dalai Lama and Desmond Tutu reflect on their long lives and share their insights on finding joy despite hardships.
During a week-long visit in April 2015, they discussed the nature of true joy, confronted obstacles such as fear, stress, and grief, and outlined the Eight Pillars of Joy. The book includes stories, wisdom, and science, as well as their daily joy practices that anchor their emotional and spiritual lives.

#22613
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
Cloud Cuckoo Land

All the Light We Cannot See


Anthony Doerr
A complex tapestry of interconnected narratives, 'Cloud Cuckoo Land' follows characters across centuries, bound by a shared story and the enduring power of imagination.
From the siege of Constantinople to a sci-fi future, their lives intertwine through a mythical text, exploring themes of survival, hope, and the importance of storytelling.
A young girl, a troubled boy, and a dedicated librarian discover a hidden text that transports them to fantastical realms, offering solace and escape from their difficult realities.
As they navigate their individual struggles, they uncover a profound connection to each other and to the ancient world.
'Cloud Cuckoo Land' celebrates the human spirit's ability to find beauty and meaning even in the face of adversity.

#3076
• Mentioned in 16 episodes
A Wizard of Earthsea

Ursula K. Le Guin
The novel is a bildungsroman that explores Ged's process of learning to cope with power and come to terms with death.
It is set in the fictional archipelago of Earthsea, where magic is based on a delicate balance maintained by wizards.
Ged's story involves his education at a school of wizardry, his struggles with a shadow he inadvertently summons, and his journey to confront and merge with this shadow.
The book is renowned for its philosophical themes, including the power of names and the balance of the universe, and is part of the six-volume Earthsea Cycle.
#
Knox


Anne Carson

#7716
• Mentioned in 7 episodes
The mushroom at the end of the world


Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing
The book follows the matsutake mushroom, a delicacy in Japan, to explore the unexpected corners of capitalism.
It delves into the worlds of Japanese gourmets, capitalist traders, Hmong jungle fighters, industrial forests, and more, highlighting the resilience of the matsutake and the entanglements between various species in surviving and creating new environments.
Tsing critiques capitalism and argues for diverse and contingent responses to understand its complexities, emphasizing the importance of multispecies assemblages and the precarious nature of life in the ruins of capitalist systems.

#83268
Primate Visions

Donna Haraway
#
Negative Space

Jilllian Linden
#56210
Always Coming Home

Denise Longrie

#
The Tombs of Atuan

Ursula K. Le Guin
The Tombs of Atuan is the second novel in the Earthsea series, following the story of Tenar, a young girl who is taken to the Tombs of Atuan and raised as a priestess of the Nameless Ones.
Her life takes an unexpected turn when she encounters Ged, the wizard from the first book, who is seeking a lost artifact hidden within the tombs.
The novel explores themes of darkness and light, freedom and captivity, and the power of choice.
Through Tenar's journey, Le Guin examines the potential for transformation and the importance of challenging established beliefs.

#2549
• Mentioned in 18 episodes
The Left Hand of Darkness

Ursula K. Le Guin
In this groundbreaking novel, Ursula K. Le Guin delves into the society of Gethen, a planet where the inhabitants are androgynous and only enter a state of sexual arousal once a month.
The story follows Genly Ai, an envoy from the Ekumen, as he navigates the complexities of Gethenian culture and politics.
The novel is a profound exploration of gender, identity, and the human condition, challenging traditional notions of masculinity and femininity.

#2695
• Mentioned in 17 episodes
Cloud Atlas


David Mitchell
Cloud Atlas is a polyphonic compendium of interlacing but nonlinear parables.
The book consists of six nested stories, each read or observed by the protagonist of the next, progressing in time through the central sixth story.
The narratives range from the journal of a 19th-century American notary to the post-apocalyptic memoir of a herdsman, Zachry.
Each story breaches time and space, linking through various characters and events.
The novel combines elements of metafiction, historical fiction, contemporary fiction, and science fiction, showcasing Mitchell's dynamic use of language and literary styles.
The book explores fundamental questions of reality, identity, and the universal themes of human predation and redemption.
#
Nazi Literature in the Americas

Roberto Bolaño

#12406
• Mentioned in 4 episodes
Three guineas

Virginia Woolf
Published in June 1938, *Three Guineas* is a non-fiction essay that responds to an imaginary letter from an educated gentleman asking for Woolf's opinion on how to prevent war.
The essay is structured as a series of responses to three different societal questions, addressing issues such as the prevention of war, the lack of support for women's education, and the barriers to women's professional employment.
Woolf critiques societal norms, patriarchal systems, and the role of women in society, advocating for gender equality and the eradication of war.
The book is characterized by its dialogue format and Woolf's pessimistic yet hopeful views on societal progression towards gender equality.

#
Appleseed

Matt Bell
A discussion of 'The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction' with David Naimon and Susan DeFreitas
