The Andrew Faris Podcast Cody Plofker Media Buying Deep Dive: Reach, Value Optimization, & Reels-First Creative
Mar 30, 2026
Cody Plofker, CEO of Jones Road Beauty and co-host of Marketing Operators, shares hands-on ecommerce and media-buying experience. He breaks down Meta reach problems and bidding history. He explores value optimization tradeoffs and measuring long-tail impression value. He champions Reels-first creative, partnership ads, and building organic creative systems. He also touches on balancing CEO duties with family life.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Reach Declines Predict Growth Plateaus
- When Jones Road's reach dropped and CPMR rose, new customer acquisition efficiency fell even as spend stayed same or increased.
- Cody traced multiple growth plateaus to reduced rolling reach, higher frequency, and more spend going to repeat customers after iOS changes.
Linear TV Added A New Signal And Boosted Reach
- Launching on linear TV gave Jones Road a new signal and noticeably improved reach even with modest spend.
- The team observed improved incrementality after TV complemented Meta spend and provided different audience exposure.
Monitor Rolling Reach Weekly
- Track rolling reach, CPMR, percent new customers and prospect-to-repeat splits weekly to diagnose performance drops.
- Cody recommends lightweight dashboards (e.g., Kurt Bullock/Produce Dept tool) to visualize trends rather than only spreadsheets.