Excerpt: The Keys of Heaven & Earth: The History of the Papacy -- pt. 2
whatshot 8 snips
Jul 4, 2025
A brisk tour of the papacy's fall and rebound after the Reformation, from Jesuit expulsions and Napoleonic imprisonment to 19th century reaction and Vatican I. Covers Catholic social teaching, Vatican II reforms, and the church's contested role in politics. Highlights scandals from the Banco Ambrosiano affair to suppression of Liberation Theology and the recent shifts under Pope Francis.
12:06
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Tocqueville’s Strange Prediction
Alexis de Tocqueville predicted America would become either entirely Unitarian or entirely Catholic, linking American voluntarism to Catholicism.
Sam Biagetti argues American influence helped make an American pope possible by the late 20th century.
insights INSIGHT
Papacy’s Political Comeback
The papacy recovered influence through 19th–20th century doctrinal moves and social teaching amid crises like Napoleon and Italian unification.
Biagetti connects this recovery to modern popes’ political assertiveness and the election of non-Italian pontiffs.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Four Non-Italian Popes In A Row
Sam recounts the string of four non-Italian popes: Polish, German, Argentinian, and now an American.
He links Pope Francis’s Jesuit background to a Vatican clean-up mission and reformist agenda.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
For Patrons only for 1 year:
We follow the tribulations of the Papacy through the aftermath of the Protestant Reformation, as the Pope's loyal soldiers in the Jesuit order are expelled from Catholic states and empires, the Church comes under attack in the French Reovlution, and Napoleon takes the Pope prisoner. We then follow the Papacy's gradual recovery of prestige -- through the reactionary rigorism of Pius IX and the 1st Vatican Council; the creation of Catholic social teaching and the intervention of the Church in the class struggle between capital and labor under Leo XIII; and the dramatic reforms of the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s. We consider the controversies and scandals of the modern church relating to fascism, the Nazi Holocaust, the Vatican Bank, and the suppression of Liberation Theology, and finally, examine the recent shakeup of the Vatican under Pope Francis, the momentous implications of the Synod on Synodality, and the clues presaging a new political assertiveness of the Church under the first American pope, Leo XIV.
To hear this lecture in its entirety, as well as all patron-only lectures from this podcast as soon as they post, sign on as a patron at any level: www.patreon.com/c/u5530632
Alternatively, to hear the patron-only lectures on the early modern age, including on Martin Luther, the Reformation, and Spain & Portugal in the age of the Inquisition, you can purchase access to the “Becoming Modern” playlist: www.patreon.com/collection/2026824?view=condensed
Image: American print showing Pope Pius IX presiding over the First Vatican Council in St. Peter's Basilica, 1869.
Correction: Banker Roberto Calvi was found dead hanging from Blackfriars Bridge, London, not London Bridge.