Historiansplaining: A historian tells you why everything you know is wrong

Excerpt: The Keys of Heaven & Earth: The History of the Papacy -- pt. 2

8 snips
Jul 4, 2025
A brisk tour of the papacy's fall and rebound after the Reformation, from Jesuit expulsions and Napoleonic imprisonment to 19th century reaction and Vatican I. Covers Catholic social teaching, Vatican II reforms, and the church's contested role in politics. Highlights scandals from the Banco Ambrosiano affair to suppression of Liberation Theology and the recent shifts under Pope Francis.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Tocqueville’s Strange Prediction

  • Alexis de Tocqueville predicted America would become either entirely Unitarian or entirely Catholic, linking American voluntarism to Catholicism.
  • Sam Biagetti argues American influence helped make an American pope possible by the late 20th century.
INSIGHT

Papacy’s Political Comeback

  • The papacy recovered influence through 19th–20th century doctrinal moves and social teaching amid crises like Napoleon and Italian unification.
  • Biagetti connects this recovery to modern popes’ political assertiveness and the election of non-Italian pontiffs.
ANECDOTE

Four Non-Italian Popes In A Row

  • Sam recounts the string of four non-Italian popes: Polish, German, Argentinian, and now an American.
  • He links Pope Francis’s Jesuit background to a Vatican clean-up mission and reformist agenda.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app