Ask Haviv Anything

Daniel Schwammenthal, Editor and commentator, shines a light on pressing issues facing Jews today. He discusses the rise of antisemitism in England and what that means for community safety. The conversation delves into the complexities of the Gaza war, including the role of international politics and the humanitarian implications. Schwammenthal also examines the dynamics of Israeli elections, particularly the challenges for new political voices. Finally, he raises concerns about social media's impact on political polarization and the ongoing discourse surrounding Israel's legitimacy.

Dive into the complex discussion around whether critiquing Israel crosses into antisemitism. Explore how genuine criticism differs from attacks on Jewish existence and Israel's legitimacy. Examine the disproportionate global focus on Israel's actions compared to other conflicts, and how social media can amplify selective outrage. Haviv warns of the biases in activism that overlook broader atrocities while reiterating that legitimate concerns about civilian deaths are valid. Ultimately, the conversation highlights the fine line between critique and denial of Jewish self-determination.

Dr. Tal Becker, Vice President of the Shalom Hartman Institute and former legal advisor to the Israeli Foreign Ministry, offers profound insights into the current landscape of antisemitism and Zionism. He discusses the paradox of Israel's strength amid rising delegitimization and the cultural roots of modern antisemitism. Tal explores the tensions within Zionism between engagement and retreat, arguing for the importance of maintaining agency. He also addresses enduring Jewish questions of safety and acceptance while advocating for proactive engagement with the world.

Explore the ongoing debate about Jewish indigeneity in Israel. The host counters claims of Jewish non-indigeneity with historical evidence from Europe and the Arab world. Discover how legal emancipation led to social antisemitism and how Arab delegates viewed Jewish nationality in the UN. Delve into the profound, centuries-long connection of Jews to the land, showcased through religious practices and cultural continuity. The revival of Hebrew serves as a testament to enduring Jewish unity despite modern attempts to separate Judaism from Israel.

Tal Shoham, a former hostage who endured a harrowing experience in Gaza, shares his incredible journey of survival and resilience. He discusses the challenges of coping with captivity, including negotiations for his life and the brutal conditions he faced in the tunnels. Tal reflects on the emotional toll of uncertainty regarding his family's safety and his efforts to rebuild trust and a sense of normalcy at home. He also offers insights on the complexities of Gazan society and the hope for national unity in Israel following recent turmoil.

In a thought-provoking conversation with Daniel Balson, former Advocacy Director for Amnesty International USA, and Danielle Haas, ex-senior editor at Human Rights Watch, the discussion centers on the dwindling credibility of major human rights NGOs. They explore how these organizations have shifted focus towards activism, neglecting core issues like international law. With insights into internal politics, methodological decline, and operational constraints, they ponder the future of human rights advocacy and the potential emergence of new grassroots movements.

Join Tom Levy, an esteemed archaeologist and author, as he delves into the fascinating world of prehistoric Israel. He shares insights from his latest graphic-novel memoir, exploring the Chalcolithic period, the origins of social inequality, and the industrial-scale copper production in Edom. Tom discusses the impact of metallurgy on social hierarchy, the role of agriculture and irrigation in early societies, and how ancient religion may have fostered community trust. His captivating anecdotes also highlight the evolution of archaeological techniques in uncovering history.

Dr. Einat Wilf, a former Knesset member and political scientist, discusses the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. She argues that the true battle lies within the ideology of Palestinianism, which often undermines Palestinian interests. Wilf critiques the failures of Israel's diplomatic efforts and explores the challenges of deradicalizing Gaza, emphasizing the need for significant political changes. The conversation also touches on the impact of global propaganda and the significance of the Abraham Accords in shifting regional dynamics.

Dan Schueftan, an Israeli national security scholar and advisor on the 2005 Gaza disengagement, shares his insights on the complex realities facing Israel and Gaza. He discusses the failures in Israeli strategy leading to recent conflicts, the cultural definitions of 'barbarism,' and the challenge of differentiating between moderate and radical Arab leaders. Schueftan emphasizes the need for military readiness alongside a pluralistic society and argues that true de-radicalization in Gaza is unlikely without local desire. He expresses skepticism about the feasibility of disarming Hamas and underscores the importance of Israeli security.

Rabbi Elhanan Miller, an Arabic-speaking educator and founder of the People of the Book project, engages in a compelling dialogue about bridging Jewish and Arab narratives. He shares his journey from journalism to rabbinic studies and the launch of his project, aimed at teaching Judaism in Arabic. Miller discusses the impact of social media on Jewish-Arab relations, his media presence during the Gaza war, and critiques Israeli policies to build credibility. He also explores political Islam, the need for new Palestinian strategies, and whether Hamas can be defeated.