This Day (An America 250 History Show)
Jody Avirgan & Radiotopia
To mark our 250th birthday, “This Day” presents "50 Weeks That Shaped America," a series of deep dives into the stories that brought us to this moment. "This Day" takes you beyond the head-spinning headlines of today and into the unexpected historical moments that have shaped American politics and culture. Hosted by Jody Avirgan (538), and historians Nicole Hemmer (Vanderbilt), and Kellie Carter Jackson (Wellesley), each episode explores a moment from that day in U.S. political history to uncover its lasting impact. On Sunday episodes, Jody, Niki and Kellie react to current news with their usual mix of humor, analysis, and historical perspective.New episodes released Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays. Lots more on our Instagram page, YouTube, and newsletter. Find it all at thisdaypod.com.This Day is a proud member of the Radiotopia podcast network from PRX.
Episodes
Mentioned books
Dec 2, 2025 • 24min
The First Vaccine Fights (Part One)
Explore the fascinating roots of vaccine skepticism in the U.S. from the 1860s to the early 1900s. Delve into the landmark Supreme Court ruling that upheld vaccination mandates and discover the origins of the anti-vaccination movement. Hear about early objections from figures like Frederick Douglass and the role of personal liberty in shaping public perception. The discussion highlights how enforcement tactics led to a backlash and raises questions about public health and civil liberties in American history.
Nov 27, 2025 • 27min
Hippo For Thanksgiving w/ Dan Pashman [Thanksgiving Week]
Dan Pashman, host of The Sporkful and a food culture expert, joins the conversation. He dives into the wild 1910 proposal to import hippos for meat in the U.S., exploring how it aimed to address hunger and ecological issues. Dan shares insights on the taste of hippo, noting it's mild and affected by preparation. The discussion shifts to how cultural framing influences our taste perceptions and modern parallels in food trends, like lab-grown meat. Plus, Dan reveals his latest pasta creation, Cascatelli!
Nov 25, 2025 • 14min
An Aid Ship To Ireland (1847) [Thanksgiving Week]
In this discussion, historian Kellie Carter Jackson, known for her insights on American history, joins to explore the 1847 voyage of the USS Jamestown. The ship carried vital relief supplies during Ireland's potato famine, highlighting an early humanitarian role for the U.S. Kellie emphasizes the remarkable unity among diverse American communities rallying for aid, including a notable donation from the Choctaw Nation. They also touch on the economic factors behind the famine and the subsequent wave of Irish migration to America, reshaping the nation's fabric.
Nov 23, 2025 • 16min
"Death By Lightning" and Chester Arthur's Rise (Some Sunday Context)
Nicole Hemmer, a historian specializing in late 19th-century politics, and Kellie Carter Jackson, an expert on political machines, delve into the unexpected rise of Chester Arthur. They explore Arthur's ascent from the corrupt New York Customs House to the presidency following Garfield's assassination. The discussion reveals how Arthur's political roots shaped his controversial tenure and his surprising shift toward civil service reform. They also touch on the moiety system's role in patronage and Arthur's legacy amid political turmoil.
Nov 20, 2025 • 23min
Evacuation Day: NYC's Forgotten Holiday (1783)
In this discussion, historians Kellie Carter Jackson and Nicole Hemmer dive into the significance of Evacuation Day in 1783, marking the British departure from New York City. Kellie vividly describes the grim realities of life under British occupation, while Nicole explores the political stakes and the treatment of freed people. They recount the day’s poignant moments, including Washington's symbolic entry and the celebration at Francis Tavern. Ultimately, they reveal how Evacuation Day faded into the background, overshadowed by the rise of Thanksgiving.
Nov 18, 2025 • 22min
The Myth of The Myth of Lewis & Clark (1805)
On November 18, 1805, Lewis and Clark returned with mixed results from their expedition. Their initially unpublished journals led to a period of obscurity. Over time, myths surrounding their journey emerged, especially highlighting Sacagawea as a key figure. Commemorative statues and public interest fluctuated, with debates on their historical portrayal. As ecological awareness grew, Lewis and Clark were recast as early environmentalists, showing how their image evolved through different eras and cultural narratives.
Nov 16, 2025 • 14min
The Penny Is Dead [Some Sunday Context]
Dive into the fascinating world of the Fugio cent, America’s first one-cent coin, designed by none other than Ben Franklin. Discover why the minting of the penny has come to an end and how rising production costs played a role. Uncover the symbols etched into the coin, from a sundial to Franklin's 'Mind Your Business' motto. Hear about the early struggles of minting and the chaos surrounding contracts that led to corruption. This rich history highlights the importance of stable currency in shaping a young nation.
Nov 13, 2025 • 26min
Sesame Street Premieres (1969)
Dive into the groundbreaking premiere of a beloved children's show that changed television forever. Discover the original Muppets and classic songs like 'Rubber Ducky.' Hear about the cultural impact and awards that made it a phenomenon. Discussions include early controversies around representation and the show's evolution to address diversity. Relive favorite moments, from iconic guest appearances to the show's nostalgic 70s aesthetic. Finally, explore how it addresses modern topics while ensuring every child feels seen.
Nov 11, 2025 • 25min
The Birth of Sesame Street (1969)
On November 10, 1969, a revolutionary children's show made its debut, sparking discussions about its cultural significance. The hosts explore the visionaries behind the creation, highlighting Joan Ganz Cooney and her collaborators. They examine the shift in television’s role, aiming to educate rather than entertain. Deliberate urban settings and groundbreaking respect for children's intelligence were key themes. The journey includes insights into the Muppets' engaging format and the thoughtful naming process, paving the way for a lasting legacy.
Nov 6, 2025 • 17min
Utah's Revolutionary Senator (1868)
On November 6, 1868, Martha Hughes Cannon made history as the first female state senator in the U.S., defeating her husband in Utah. The hosts dive into her impressive journey from medicine to politics, illuminating the role of polygamy in Utah's politics and how it shaped women's rights. Cannon's activism and connections with suffragists like Susan B. Anthony are highlighted, along with her groundbreaking legislative efforts. Despite her significant accomplishments, the podcast explores why her legacy has faded over time.
