Scotty Harper
Former family pastor and central participant in the case who pleaded guilty to murdering Thad Reynolds; appears via interviews and recorded confessions describing his relationship with Michelle and the killing.
Best podcasts with Scotty Harper
Ranked by the Snipd community
17 snips
Apr 1, 2026 • 1h 25min
The Secret Life of the Homecoming Queen
Scotty Harper, a former family pastor who later confessed to killing Thad Reynolds. Michelle Reynolds, a former homecoming queen who recounts her affair and the fallout. They discuss a secret affair with coded messages, mounting tension and a plotted confrontation, the discovery of Thad’s stabbing, key evidence and recordings, and the legal unraveling that followed.
