
Scott Renshaw
Arts and entertainment/film critic for Salt Lake City Weekly and co-host of Mousterpiece Melodies, contributing critical analysis and anecdotes about Up during the episode.
Best podcasts with Scott Renshaw
Ranked by the Snipd community

Mar 6, 2026 • 1h 52min
84: Up with Josh Spiegel & Scott Renshaw
Scott Renshaw, Salt Lake City Weekly film critic and co‑host of Mousterpiece Melodies. Josh Spiegel, film critic and Mousterpiece Melodies co‑host. They revisit Pixar’s Up: the emotional opening montage, Carl’s unusual elderly lead, Giacchino’s Oscar‑winning score, themes of aging and grief, humor and adventure, worldbuilding and pacing, and the film’s legacy and awards.


