The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Bears STUN Packers, Rams SURVIVE Panthers on NFL Wild Card Weekend
Jan 11, 2026
John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and football analyst, breaks down the thrilling Wild Card Weekend. He celebrates Caleb Williams' heroics in the Bears' comeback against the Packers, questioning if Matt LaFleur's job is at risk following the loss. John shares insights on the Rams' narrow escape against the Panthers, criticizing Matthew Stafford's inconsistency and the team's special teams blunders. He also discusses the future of both teams in the playoffs, providing a candid assessment of their potential.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Don't Gamble Deep In Your Own Territory
- Avoid going for fourth-down gambles in your own territory early; play the game out and protect field position.
- Middlekauff criticizes risky fourth-down calls as moronic when leading and still deep in your own half.
Turnovers Mask Coverage Issues
- The Bears' defense repeatedly produced timely turnovers despite coverage flaws, flipping momentum late.
- Middlekauff credits opportunistic plays and special moments rather than consistent coverage for Chicago's success.
Caleb's Unique Playmaking Ceiling
- Caleb Williams made a season-defining fourth-and-long play rolling left for a critical completion under pressure.
- Middlekauff argues Williams' elite physical traits allow him to make unique, game-saving throws other QBs can't.