
The Self Publishing Show SPS-440: Author Under Attack James Blatch & Cissy Mecca
Mar 26, 2026
They unpack two publishing controversies: an author dropped amid AI-writing accusations and a literary agent telling writers to avoid the London Book Fair. They explore AI-detection problems, gatekeeping in publishing, and how public accusations affect writers. Conversations also touch on burnout, writing routines, and balancing creativity with the business side of being an author.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Project Hail Mary Film Lost The Book's Subtlety
- James recounts reading Project Hail Mary and finding the film adaptation flattened the protagonist compared to the book.
- He contrasts the book's slow, scientific reveal with a film that made the lead more infantile and less faithful to the novel's tone.
Agent Called Writers Wannabe At London Book Fair
- James describes a TikTok clip from agent Alice S.H. who called interrupted writers "wannabe authors" at the London Book Fair.
- James argues the clip felt sneery and representative of traditional publishing gatekeeping being out of touch with today's indie-first reality.
Build An Audience Before Chasing Traditional Deals
- Do consider self-publishing first to build an audience and negotiating leverage before chasing traditional deals.
- James recommends honing craft and proving sales as better leverage than begging agents and publishers through the old query treadmill.







