Mind Chat Christmas Special: Panpsychism or Illusionism?
02:47:56
Conversion To Panpsychism
- Philip Goff describes an adult discovery of panpsychism after rejecting materialism.
Consciousness As Fundamental Aspect
- Panpsychism treats consciousness as a fundamental, ubiquitous aspect of matter.
- It explains human consciousness by combining simpler intrinsic experiential natures in complex systems like brains.
Illusionism Avoids Scientific Overhaul
- Philip Goff frames illusionism as denying phenomenal properties to avoid a radical rewrite of science.
- Illusionism instead explains why we think qualia exist by describing misleading cognitive mechanisms.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right 15 chevron_right 16 chevron_right 17 chevron_right 18 chevron_right 19 chevron_right 20 chevron_right 21 chevron_right 22 chevron_right 23 chevron_right 24 chevron_right 25 chevron_right 26 chevron_right 27 chevron_right 28 chevron_right 29 chevron_right 30 chevron_right 31 chevron_right 32 chevron_right 33 chevron_right 34 chevron_right 35 chevron_right 36 chevron_right 37 chevron_right 38 chevron_right 39 chevron_right 40 chevron_right 41 chevron_right 42 chevron_right 43 chevron_right 44 chevron_right 45 chevron_right 46 chevron_right 47 chevron_right 48 chevron_right 49 chevron_right 50 chevron_right 51 chevron_right 52 chevron_right 53 chevron_right 54 chevron_right 55 chevron_right 56 chevron_right 57 chevron_right 58 chevron_right 59 chevron_right 60 chevron_right
Introduction
00:00 • 3min
I've Got a Joke, I'm a Fool.
03:06 • 2min
A Christmas Special for You, Mid Wintersher Festivus.
05:28 • 2min
What's Coming Up?
07:33 • 2min
The Man Behind the Illusion
09:06 • 4min
I've Always Been Obsessed by the Mystery of Consciousness
12:58 • 3min
What Is Serite's Paradox?
16:02 • 4min
Is There a Magic Circle of Creatures?
20:11 • 2min
I Think a Lot of People Have That Intuition
22:14 • 2min
The Quick Fire Round - God, Free Will and Objective Morality
24:03 • 3min
Is There Evidence for Gold Directed Activity?
27:06 • 3min
The Fine Tuning Argument for God A
30:23 • 2min
The Importance of Humanism
32:27 • 3min
Is It Ok to Assume That This Radical Error Theory Is a False?
35:30 • 2min
Pansychism and Illusionism
37:40 • 6min
The Inner Aspect of Matter in Brains
43:34 • 4min
Preymuch, I'm Happy With That.
47:32 • 5min
The Illusionist Project
52:41 • 3min
I Wasn't the Main Driving Argument the Thin Compondedet?
55:35 • 2min
Are You Really This Uncharitable?
57:23 • 2min
Panpsychism Enables or Eliminates the Possibility of Explaining Consciousness?
59:26 • 6min
Is Consciousness More Fundamental Than Computing or Neural Processing?
01:05:11 • 3min
What Would Induce Me to Trust Introspection?
01:08:12 • 2min
Is Consciousness Fundamental?
01:10:11 • 2min
Is It Changed Your Experience of the Wine?
01:12:34 • 5min
I'm a Psychonite, a Psychic, and I'll O You, Ye
01:17:52 • 2min
What Are the Biggest Developments in Psychics?
01:19:49 • 3min
The Co Consciousness Relation
01:23:01 • 5min
Is There a Correlation Between Personality Type and Preferential Theory of Consciousness?
01:27:42 • 4min
You Can't Face Up to Reality, Man, You Know, I'm Not.
01:32:00 • 2min
Sentientism and Sensitivity
01:34:26 • 3min
Veganism Is a Trickier Position to Adopt
01:37:05 • 3min
Can Consciousness Be Vague?
01:40:12 • 2min
The Mind Chap Podcast - Questions for Keith
01:42:29 • 2min
Is There a Difference Between Computing and Computing?
01:44:08 • 2min
What Are the Properties of Qualia?
01:45:57 • 3min
Is There a Difference Between Qualia and Ontology?
01:49:03 • 3min
Starting Points
01:51:46 • 2min
You Seem to Have Qualia Qualia, if Yo Fro to Have Red Ball Quietly?
01:54:14 • 2min
Rigter, What's the Argument for Illusionism?
01:56:36 • 2min
The Starting Point of Illusionism
01:58:22 • 2min
Is There a Difference Between Red and Blue Experiences?
02:00:33 • 4min
Aren't Representations of Qalia Just as Impossible to Account For?
02:04:34 • 3min
Is the Illusion of Red Qualities?
02:07:10 • 3min
Is There a Consciousness?
02:09:41 • 4min
Are You a Strong Emergentist?
02:13:14 • 2min
Manipulations on the Causal Factor
02:14:51 • 2min
Is There a Constraint on the Theory That the World Doesn't Work Like That?
02:16:21 • 2min
What Is Consciousness?
02:18:37 • 2min
Is There a Non Mental Nature to Matter?
02:20:45 • 2min
Is It a Pure Panpychis?
02:22:20 • 3min
The Relationship Between an Object and Its Properties
02:25:19 • 3min
Is the Relational View Getting You in a Regress?
02:27:52 • 2min
The Knowledge Argument
02:30:00 • 6min
Is She Just Doesn't Learn?
02:35:44 • 2min
Is Consciousness Panpsychism or Illusionism?
02:37:32 • 2min
You Can't Have Your Phenomenon on the Cheap, Don'twe?
02:39:35 • 1min
Is There a New Form of Consciousness?
02:41:02 • 3min
Panpsychism Is the True Theory of Consciousness
02:44:20 • 2min
Is Tat Reality Plush?
02:46:04 • 2min
In the Mind Chat Christmas special, Keith and Philip take it in turns to interrogate each other about their favoured view of consciousness (illusionism and panpsychism, respectively), based in part on viewers' questions. The episode will culminate in a 15 min twitter poll, in which viewers will decide once and for all whether panpsychism or illusionism is the correct view of consciousness.