Why Your Compensation System Keeps Drifting (And How to Stop It)

What would it mean for your school to actually have a compensation system rather than just a collection of decisions made under pressure? Cliff Kling has spent two years at Mission & Data helping independent schools answer that question, and before that, 24 years inside schools as CFO, general counsel, and president. His vantage point is rare: he has lived the problem from the inside and now helps schools solve it from the outside.

In this conversation, Cliff walks through why faculty compensation keeps breaking down in independent schools, why the basic laws of supply and demand do not apply here the way leaders often assume, and what it actually takes to build a system that is fair, transparent, and sustainable over time.

He covers the shift from loyalty-based to lifestyle-based employment contracts, the three-legged stool of salary design, evaluation, and benefits, the honest trade-offs between step-and-lane and banded systems, and why implementation almost always fails when schools try to move too fast. If your school has ever patched a compensation problem instead of fixing it, this episode will show you what it actually takes to fix it.

New for Moonshot Lab members: a premium version of the Independent School Moonshot Podcast! Members receive extended, members-only conversations through a private podcast feed, available exclusively inside Moonshot Lab.

What You'll Learn from Cliff Kling:

1. The Breakdown of Supply and Demand: While demand for teachers remains high, the national supply has plummeted-falling from 180,000 education degrees in the 1970s to just 86,000 in 2020. Traditional market corrections are stalled by school financial models that rely heavily on personnel costs and tuition ceilings.
2. The Lifestyle Contract Shift: The workforce has moved away from the 20th-century loyalty contract toward a lifestyle contract. Modern employees prioritize flexibility, total rewards, and continued relevance over long-term tenure and traditional pensions.
3. The Perils of System Creep: Without a rigorous system, schools often drift into having dozens of individual negotiated contracts. This leads to inequity where newer hires earn nearly as much as veterans with 20 years of experience, creating deep-seated resentment.
4. The Closed System Design Challenge: Effective redesign requires treating compensation as a closed system during the planning phase. By working with existing budget dollars first, schools are forced to make honest trade-offs between salary increases and benefit enhancements before adding new funds.
5. Defining the Role is a Prerequisite: Fixing pay requires first defining the specific expectations of a full-time teacher. This clarity sets a baseline for what is covered by a base salary versus what truly earns a stipend.