The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - 49ers UPSET Eagles, Patriots DEFEAT Chargers, Bills EDGE Jaguars on NFL Wild Card Sunday
Jan 12, 2026
A former NFL scout dives into the surprising upset of the Eagles by the 49ers, showcasing their remarkable resilience despite injuries. The breakdown of the Patriots' staunch defense against the Chargers highlights their dominance. Meanwhile, the Bills' comeback against the Jaguars shines a spotlight on Josh Allen's phenomenal performance. The podcast also touches on coaching volatility, the challenges faced by Justin Herbert, and Matt Ryan's new role with the Falcons, making it a must-listen for sports fans.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
49ers' Character Trumped Injuries
- The 49ers won despite massive injuries because they maintained character and adaptability.
- John Middlekauff argues coaching and mentality, not just talent, decided the upset.
Sirianni's Job Value Is Inflated By Environment
- Sirianni benefited from elite roster construction and front-office support more than coaching brilliance.
- Middlekauff says Sirianni likely wouldn't get hired as a head coach elsewhere despite playoff appearances.
Eagles Misused Jalen Hurts' Strengths
- The Eagles offense underperformed in coaching and play-calling, especially in leveraging Jalen Hurts' rushing ability.
- Middlekauff criticizes the offense for avoiding what Hurts does best and calls the coaching combo ineffective.