Money Meets Medicine

Should Physicians Buy or Rent? How Much Should A Doctor Spend Buying a Home?

Mar 25, 2026
Justin Harvey, CFP at APM Wealth, advises physicians on financial planning and housing choices. He compares buying versus renting timelines, explains how city differences shift the math, and warns against income-multiple rules. Short, practical guidance on affordability, mortgage cash-flow limits, and when renting as a trainee can be smarter.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Buying Usually Needs About Five Years To Break Even

  • Zillow found the average buy vs rent break-even is 4.7 years in 2024.
  • At ~6% mortgage rates this still hovers around four years, so many 3–4 year residents won't break even if they buy.
ADVICE

Rent During Training Unless You’re Rooted

  • If you can rent while relocating for training, prefer renting to avoid the financial and logistical risk of buying mid-training.
  • Buying may make sense if you're settled (married, kids, or a stay-at-home spouse) or the local market strongly favors ownership.
INSIGHT

City Choice Completely Changes Buy vs Rent Math

  • Break-even time varies dramatically by city (e.g., Cleveland ~2 years, Boston ~8, New York ~10, San Francisco ~15).
  • Local market delta between buy vs rent drives whether buying makes financial sense during training.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app