Works in Progress Podcast

Should we ban ugly buildings?

13 snips
Nov 24, 2025
In this discussion, Samuel, an architecture contributor focused on conservation debates, shares insights on the YIMBY movement's division over aesthetics. He argues that aesthetic regulations can foster goodwill and curb opposition to development. They dissect the fine line between genuine complaints and those masking economic motives. The conversation explores how unified ownership and pattern-book designs can enhance visual appeal, while analyzing the mixed results of discretionary design reviews. Ultimately, the team advocates for local codes to balance beauty and function.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Public Prefers Older Architectural Styles

  • Public opinion strongly favors older-looking buildings in aesthetic rankings.
  • Surveys show people typically rank older hospitals and civic buildings as more attractive than newer ones.
ADVICE

Use Good Imagery To Win Support

  • Show attractive renderings to build public support for densification projects.
  • Presenting appealing images changes how policies land in national and local politics.
ANECDOTE

Auckland Upzoning Produced Ugly Examples

  • Ben reviewed Auckland upzoning outcomes and found many new buildings unattractive and plasticky.
  • Opponents exploited the ugliest examples to rally resistance to upzoning.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app