The Note Closers Show - The #1 Podcast for Note Investing

What Cities Have The Highest (and Lowest) Levels of Accidental Landlords in America?

Mar 13, 2026

Ask episode

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

The Rise of the Accidental Landlord: Turning Market Stalls into Strategic Wins

What do you do when you’ve got a property for sale that simply won’t move? Maybe you’ve taken a new job, moved for family reasons, or are facing a financial shift, but you’re unwilling to slash your price by tens of thousands of dollars. If this sounds familiar, you aren’t alone—you are likely becoming an "accidental landlord". According to recent Zillow data, we are currently at a three-year high for homeowners who, unable to secure their desired sale price, have pivoted to renting their properties out instead. In this episode, we dive into the data behind this shift, the cities leading the charge, and the practical steps you need to take if you find yourself managing a rental you never planned for.

5 Key Topics Covered in This Episode

The "Choice-Driven" Market Shift: Unlike the "shock-driven" market of late 2022 when mortgage rates first skyrocketed, the current trend is driven by choice. Homeowners today aren't necessarily in distress; rather, they are refusing to settle for less than what their "heart says their home is worth" and are using renting as a way to "buy time" until the sales market rebalances.

The Texas and Florida Factor: A staggering 7 out of the top 10 metros for accidental landlords are in Texas or Florida. While Denver holds the #1 spot, Texas dominates the list with Houston (#2), Austin (#3), San Antonio (#4), and Dallas (#8) all seeing high percentages of for-sale listings re-entering the market as rentals.

Property Type Disparity: Single-family detached homes are the most common property type for accidental landlords, making up 3.4% of rental listings. However, condos are seeing the fastest growth in this trend, as they are often less sensitive to interest rate fluctuations but more sensitive to shifts in urban buyer demand.

Pitfalls of New Landlords: Managing a property isn't as simple as collecting a check. Scott Carson shares personal lessons on the dangers of property managers holding reserve funds that can put you behind on your mortgage, as well as the critical importance of running background checks and requiring ACH or cashier's checks to avoid the nightmare of bounced payments and lengthy evictions.

Creative Exit Strategies: If you don't want to be a landlord, there are alternatives. The episode explores creative finance options like wrap-around mortgages, owner financing, or even short sales if you are upside down on the property. These strategies can often provide a better outcome than traditional renting for those who aren't built for property management.

Becoming an accidental landlord is often the result of "good things happening to good people" or simply a shifting economic tide. While it can be a headache, it is also an opportunity to build long-term wealth if handled correctly. The key is to take the emotion out of the game, look at the black-and-white numbers, and understand your local market competition. Whether you choose to hire a professional property manager or pivot to a creative finance exit, remember that you don't have to navigate this journey alone. Reach out to experts, use the right tools like Rentometer, and make sure your next move is a calculated one. Stop waiting for the market to change and start taking action to make the market work for you.