
The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - Super Bowl Week Preview: Darnold From Bust To Top Ten QB, Seahawks Valuation Too Low, Vikings Fire GM, Kubiak Will Succeed
Feb 3, 2026
John Middlekauff, former NFL scout and podcast host, gives sharp front-office and talent-evaluation perspective. They dissect the Vikings' GM firing and the JJ McCarthy fallout. They weigh Klint Kubiak’s fit in Las Vegas and possible roster-reset moves. They debate Sam Darnold’s surprising resurgence and where he could rank if he wins it all. They also argue the Seahawks are undervalued compared to recent franchise sales.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Back Coaches Who Fit Your Roster
- Colin and John recommend backing young offensive hires like Clint Kubiak who fit roster strengths and long-term planning.
- They suggest teams take a multi-year view and prioritize scheme fit over short-term fixes.
Don't Hesitate To Reset With Assets
- John advises trading high-value assets like Maxx Crosby if it resets a franchise and accelerates rebuilding.
- He frames trading stars as an acceptable reset when short-term competitiveness is unlikely.
Second Chances Change QB Labels
- Colin argues modern QB evaluation tolerates early failures because system and context matter more than initial label.
- John says Sam Darnold's physical traits and late-career polish prove second chances can produce top-10 QBs.

