Catholic Answers Live #12707 How Do I Get Better at Debating Protestants? AMA: Dropped Calls - Joe Heschmeyer
May 7, 2026
Joe Heschmeyer, Catholic apologist and host of Shameless Popery, shares how he prepares for debates and why his approach resonates online. He discusses practical study tips for apologetics. The conversation also tackles a disputed Vatican I quote, when online Mass counts, Protestant resistance to Marian devotion, and whether apostles were married.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Shameless Popery Growth Linked To Renewed Curiosity
- Joe attributes Shameless Popery's growth to widespread curiosity and internet access to historic Catholic answers.
- He notes rising Easter Vigil entrants and people correcting long-held half-truths about Catholic teaching online.
How To Prepare Effectively For Debates
- Prepare early and focus on important, winnable topics like sola scriptura when agreeing to debates.
- Research your opponent's past arguments, watch prior debates (e.g., Gavin Ortlund vs. Trent Horn), and cram last-minute to refine responses.
Start With Charity And Discipleship
- Ground your apologetics in charity and personal discipleship before trying to persuade others.
- Study Scripture, Church history, learn opponents' reasons, practice explaining their view charitably, and accept being bad before you're good.
