
The BREAK—DOWN Beyond Techno-Optimism w/ David Edgerton
11 snips
Jan 14, 2026 David Edgerton, historian of science and industry, rethinks how production and technology shape the climate crisis. He questions tech optimism, explores China’s role as both polluter and clean‑tech maker, critiques nostalgic industrial revivalism, and warns against AI and innovation hype that preserve the status quo.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Lost Alternatives Like Early Electric Cars
- Many inventions and innovations are historical failures and never became dominant.
- Edgerton points to early 20th-century electric cars as one surprising example of lost alternatives.
China: Emitter And Green-Tech Powerhouse
- China's rise is simultaneously the main driver of current emissions and the world's leading producer of low-cost green hardware.
- Green manufacturing itself generates emissions and depends on existing fossil-fuel systems, so it's not a simple solution.
No Simple Energy Transitions Exist
- There hasn't been neat 'transitions' that replace old energy systems; instead production accumulates and expands.
- We now use more coal and steel than ever, so adding renewables doesn't automatically displace fossil fuels.






