The Free Will Show

Episode 115: Abilities with Barbara Vetter

Mar 16, 2026
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Agentive Modality Is Distinct From Standard Modality

  • Agentive modality is a distinct kind of modality tied to action and control rather than standard possibility/necessity logic.
  • Examples like Kenny's card and darts cases show can-as-ability fails distribution and T-axiom of modal logic.
INSIGHT

Abilities Are Controlled Capacities Not Mere Dispositions

  • Abilities are agent properties that grant control over actions and differ from dispositions and opportunities.
  • Dispositions happen to you; opportunities are environmental — abilities are controlled capacities of agents.
INSIGHT

Simple Success Doesn't Prove Robust Ability

  • Distinguish simple abilities (one-off successes) from robust/general abilities (stable capacities).
  • Lewis's Finnish example and dice/darts flukes show simple success doesn't establish a robust ability.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app