ThePrint ThePrintPod: Mamata says ECI transferred officers by breaking convention. What former ECs say on the norm
Mar 19, 2026
A political storm over sudden transfers of 44 officers in four states sparks debate. Claims that customary consultation with state governments was bypassed. Former election commissioners explain the panel-of-three convention and when pre-election moves are typical. Details of high-level replacements in West Bengal and wider postings across Tamil Nadu, Assam and Kerala are highlighted.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
ECI Normally Seeks Three-Name Panel From States
- The Election Commission usually asks state governments for a panel of three officers before making transfers during elections.
- Former CEC S. Y. Qureshi says this convention lets the commission pick one suitable officer while respecting state ownership of officers.
Midnight Transfer After Money Distribution Complaint
- The ECI once transferred a police commissioner at midnight after a complaint about money distribution and ordered implementation within half an hour.
- Qureshi used this example to show emergency transfers can bypass the panel when speed is critical.
Pre-Election Systematic Shifts Follow Internal Guidelines
- The ECI conducts pre-election shifts of officers who've served three years in election-related posts and may move officials from their home districts.
- Ashok Lavasa says this follows internal guidelines and requires a certificate from the Chief Secretary before announcing elections.