Safety Labs by Safety Products Global

The Dangers of Safety Incentives with Diane Chadwick-Jones

Jan 12, 2026
Diane Chadwick-Jones, former BP safety leader and researcher on incentives, explains why tying pay to injury rates can backfire. She recounts how policies suppressed reporting, how BP shifted to peer recognition, and why transparency and supportive leadership matter. Practical tips cover influencing executives, changing belief systems, and training future safety professionals.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Six Sigma Project Exposed Patchy Reporting

  • Diane's Six Sigma work at BP found patchy reporting and fears that reporting could reduce bonuses.
  • Interviews revealed technical system issues plus perceived pay consequences that varied widely across sites.
INSIGHT

Injury-Linked Bonuses Suppress Reporting

  • Linking pay or bonuses to injury counts suppresses reporting and reduces learning.
  • Diane Chadwick-Jones found rewards push people to hide incidents so organizations lose the small signals that prevent bigger accidents.
ANECDOTE

BP Replaced Injury Bonuses With Peer Recognition

  • BP removed injuries from the annual cash bonus in 2019 but retained seep and spill metrics.
  • They introduced an Energize peer-recognition points scheme for immediate thanks and social recognition that managers approve.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app