Stuff You Should Know Selects: What Was the Deal With the Hatfields and McCoys?
Jan 16, 2021
Dive into the infamous Hatfields vs. McCoys feud, a tale of 19th-century Appalachia filled with unexpected twists. Discover the roots of their rivalry, ignited by a stolen pig, and the complexities of loyalty and enmity post-Civil War. Learn about the contentious trial involving hog theft that underscored deep family divisions. Explore the violent clashes, cultural implications, and the surprising partnership between the families during World War II. This legendary feud is more than just folklore; it's a story of emotion, conflict, and eventual reconciliation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Simmering Tensions
- Tensions remained high even without major incidents. Minor skirmishes and distrust were common between the families.
- The "pig incident," involving the alleged theft of several pigs, became a pivotal point in the feud.
The Pig Trial
- Randall McCoy accused Floyd Hatfield of stealing pigs and took him to court. The magistrate, Preacher Hatfield, tried to ensure a fair trial with a mixed jury.
- Selkirk McCoy, influenced by his employment with Devil Anse, sided with the Hatfields, leading to Floyd's acquittal and Randall's fury.
Escalating Violence
- Randall McCoy's bitterness over the trial intensified the conflict, leading to increased violence between the families.
- A Hatfield son, after an argument about the hogs, assaulted Randall by crushing his mouth with a rock.
