Episode 04: Interview with Shade Whitesel

SHOW NOTES:

Summary:

Shade Whitesel has been training and competing in dog sports since she was a kid.

Always interested in how dogs learned, she has successfully competed in Schutzhund, AKC obedience and French Ring.

What started out as an experiment, competing at the national level in IPO without the use of an e collar, has now turned into a firm commitment to positive training and the desire to teach other trainers and dogs how to be successful in bitesports with as little punishment as possible.

Her focus as a trainer is on clear communication with your dog -- as we discuss in the podcast, she believes this relieves frustration and improves the overall quality of the dog's work.

Next Episode:

To be released 2/17/2017, featuring Loretta Mueller.

TRANSCRIPTION:

Melissa Breau: This is Melissa Breau and you're listening to the Fenzi Dog Sports podcast brought to you by the Fenzi Dog Sports Academy, an online school dedicated to providing high quality instruction for competitive dog sports using only the most current and progressive training methods.

Today we'll be talking to Shade Whitesel. Shade has been training and competing in dog sports since she was a kid. Always interested in how dogs learned, she has successfully competed in Schutzhund, AKC obedience and French Ring.

What started out as an experiment, competing at the national level in IPO without the use of an e collar, has now turned into a firm commitment to positive training and the desire to teach other trainers and dogs how to be successful in bitesports with as little punishment as possible. Hi, Shade. Welcome to the podcast.

Shade Whitesel: Hi, Melissa.

Melissa Breau: So, to start out can you tell me a little bit about the dogs you have now and what you're working on with them?

Shade Whitesel: Sure. My youngest dog is Ones who is 4 years old and he just recently earned his Schutzhund 2 in December. I'm looking forward to getting his Schutzhund 3 this spring and then going on to compete nationally with him if it looks like we're a good enough team.

Briefly, Schutzhund is kind of like a triathlon for dogs, based on police work. It requires tracking, where they have to follow a person's track and indicate articles that the person's dropped, and then an obedience portion, and then a protection portion. So, Ones attained pretty good scores in his one and his two, and I'm excited about his future career.

I tend to do AKC later in the dog's career, since it's easier on their bodies than bitesports. I also have Baileys, Ones's sister, who was returned to me a year ago and we've start setting the foundation for AKC obedience, and she's coming along.

She's been teaching me a lot about working an older dog with established habits before I got them. So, kind of what to do with that and how to retrain.

And Reiki my old guy, he's both Ones's and Bailey's dad, he's 10 years old and I had really hoped to get him in the AKC utility ring. He's got his CDX, but he's getting older there so we'll see. And he has numerous IPO 3's. We competed nationally for four years, that kind of thing, and he did really well. So, that's my current dogs.

Melissa Breau: Awesome. And they're all German Shepherds, right?

Shade Whitesel: They are. I have only German Shepherds right now and I'll add a couple of more breeds eventually, but right now because of Schutzhund, I need to do the bite work and so I've chosen the German Shepherd as my breed for that.

Melissa Breau: How did you get into competitive dog sports and training?

Shade Whitesel: Well, I always wanted a dog when I was a kid and I finally got a mixed breed dog. And at that time, your training classes were kind of like AKC obedience and she did really well in her training class, but I couldn't compete with her because she was a mixed breed.

So, I always wanted to kind of compete and then when I got my first purebred dog I got interested in Schutzhund because it's a breed test for the Shepherds. And I started really getting into it and getting titles on the dogs.

So, that kind of morphed into people asking me to give training lessons to them and once I put a Schutzhund 1 on a dog then I figured that I could at least start training other people. So, that's kind of when it morphed into becoming a professional dog trainer.

Melissa Breau: I've heard you talk before a little bit about your positive training journey and kind of what got you started. But can you kind of share it for the audience?

Shade Whitesel: Yeah. In bite work sports and in Schutzhund training you're normally dealing with pretty strong dogs physically and mentally, that really like to bite. So, they have lots of reinforcement history for biting, whether that is the ball or the tug, or the bad guy.

And there's a culture correction in this sport when it comes to getting control. Because these dogs are really strong willed and eventually you have to get obedience around that high value reinforcer, there's a lot of correction involved.

When I first started doing Schutzhund I definitely was no different than anyone else. I used a lot of correction with my dogs, but I really started breaking down the behaviors much more than anyone I knew at the time. Teaching them at lower arousal, breaking it down in much tinier steps... and then I realized that I could use the helper as a reward.

So, for instance, "Hey, dog heel two steps and then I'll send you to the helper for a bite," and then I really started questioning all the correction, because that worked so well. And so, I kind of started out as a trainer using a lot of correction and then figuring out, and gradually getting more positive as I went till what I am right now.

Melissa Breau: And I've seen some of your videos. I mean, you really truly manage to get that same precision and that beauty in the performance that I think most people are looking for. And I know from talking to you, you really do, do it completely positive so it's really impressive.

Shade Whitesel: I think there's this thing that sometimes...I remember in Schutzhund even when I used correction we always said we use the ball for reward, but we can't get as precise behaviors when you do that and that was the argument against using a lot of motivation. And I always was like, "Well, I want both. I want the motivation, I want the strongness and then I want the preciseness."

So, even when I was figuring out how to do it without correction I was like, "I don't want to sacrifice anything. I still want really high quality behaviors," and since Reiki took me to Nationals, now I'm not satisfied with anything other than as good as I can get. So, yeah, it's been a journey. That's a cliché thing, but it's definitely been a journey to figure out how to do that.

Melissa: So, how would you describe your training philosophy now?

Shade Whitesel: Right now, I feel like I haven't said no to any of my dogs for like four years. No. Seriously, I'm really currently most interested in what the dog is feeling about our training session and what their emotional state is.

That's been my task. Ones has been definitely my teacher in that way, because I really need to know what his emotional state is in bite work. They'll tell you way before the behavior skills breakdown. Either lost focus, stressing, whatever that looks like. So, that's currently what I'm really into, trying to figure out how the dog feels and what that tells me of my training plan. And that kind of segues into creating the toy play as a reinforcement.

So many of us use toys with our dogs because we realize how joyful they can get with that and how excited. But we could get much more efficient training done if we created more of a significant reinforcement if we had some rules in there like bring the toy back. When they all of a sudden don't drop the toy they're not being belligerent, they're pretty much telling us our rate of reinforcement wasn't up as much as it should be in the training plan. Also, when we use toys to teach stuff it gives us ways to work through high arousal situations, like, we're going to encounter in agility or bite work, or anything else a dog wants.

I mean really a high arousal situation for my dogs is going from the car to the beach. That's a situation where they have to be on leash and it is none too fun if I can't get them to walk calmly from point A to point B.

So, the toy play reinforcement gives us ways to work through that. I'd say that Ones is my most positively trained dog to date, since he's my youngest and I bred him so I've known him since minute one. I feel like sometimes I've gotten so positive in my teaching that most cases where we use negative punishment I look at that and I'm like, "We could teach that without even that." So, I feel like I've swung really far in a very positive way in my training, which is good.

Melissa Breau: And just in case anybody's not familiar with the four quadrants. Negative punish is the removal of something the dog doesn't like, right?

Shade Whitesel: Exactly. And we as positive trainers tend to use that when we don't know what else to do or when we're having a dog that's doing behaviors we don't like. That's accepted for us to go there and it can be good. There's still some fallout sometimes, but it can be a polishing technique.

Melissa Breau: So, I was super lucky. I got to shadow you at FDSA Training Camp last year. I have to say I definitely learned a ton following you around for a couple of days.

Shade Whitesel: And I appreciated your technical skills, because I don't have any.

Melissa Breau: Well, it was a pleasure to get to follow you around. I feel like I learned so, so much. And some of my favorites were just listening to you talk about play and how you structure some of that. And just some of the takeaways that I got at camp definitely I brought them home and worked with my own dog differently, and it really has had an impact.

Shade Whitesel: Well, good. Yeah.

Melissa Breau: So, it included everything from play to location specific markers... kind of, you ran the gambit, I think, at camp last year and it seems like, or at least seems to me, that there's a theme that kind of runs through all of your FDSA classes and all of the talks that I've heard you give — this idea of communicating as clearly as possible with your dogs. So, do you mind just sharing a little bit why you feel that's so critical?

Shade Whitesel: No matter how you train, communicating as clearly as possible is so important, because 99.9 percent of our problems are due to the unclarity of our teaching.

And all of our problems with dogs — I mean it's really our problem it's not theirs — go away when you look at the clarity, or more accurately the 'not clarity' of your teaching.

When your communication is clear arousal levels go down, frustration from your learner dog goes down, and you get more confident and fluent behaviors from them. And this holds true over trialing, over living with them, over everything, just to be as clear as possible and predictable, that goes into predictability too. So, no matter what method you do that is just so important I think — obviously, since I talk about it.

Melissa Breau: So, I think one really good example of that is the work you've done with location specific markers. Do you mind just briefly kind of explaining what that means and kind of how you use them?

Shade Whitesel: You know, markers are such a good thing and people are exploring them, and figuring out that it's really nice to bridge what behavior your dogs doing to get their reward. Tell the dog where to collect their reinforcement, like, technically I want a different marker that means collect it from my hands, whether that's food or a toy and I want a different marker that means collect it away from there, whether it's go pick-up the toy on the ground or whether I'm going to throw the toy, and again it's just that clarity. And I notice with my own dogs if I had a different marker word for, "Strike the tug out of my hand," versus, "I'm going to throw it," the dog stopped mugging me, they stopped looking for where the toy was all the time when I was asking for behaviors. Because they knew that I would tell them exactly how to get their reinforcement. And again, it just goes back to the clarity.

So, location specific markers is just the dog knows exactly where to go and they don't have to be checking where the toy is or the food — is the food in your pocket? Is it over there in the dish? Because you're going to tell them so they can put 100 percent of their attention to figuring out what behavior you want them to do, because they can trust that you're going to tell them where the reinforcement is.

Melissa Breau: I think a lot of trainers tend to rely really heavily on one or two training methods. So, somebody may lean really heavily on shaping, while somebody else tends to mostly lure behaviors or throw a ball, or whatever. I know that in the current session at FDSA, which will be current when this goes live, you're going to be teaching a class to help handlers better use all of their tools. Do you mind just talking a little bit about what that class is, and what it's about?

Shade Whitesel: Yeah. I think the more we know and feel comfortable about all the positive ways we can train our dogs the more effective we're going to be as a teacher. And then, if we know how to lure and we know how to shape, and we know how to capture, we can then be more informed about what technique that we want to use to teach a certain behavior. I think we all could use a little more knowledge on how to get behaviors on cue. How to name it, how to get it on stimulus control, whether that behavior is lured or shaped and the one constant that I know I always struggle with is timing. Click, pause, treat.

And I see many students coming through the academy, who are great at one technique, but they're kind of unsure of the other techniques and I'd like to help out with that. I'd like to teach that and help people figure out what effective technique they want to use to teach their dog a behavior.

Melissa Breau: Now, does the class have specific behaviors that you try and work on through the course of the class? Are the students going to pick their own behavior and use different techniques to accomplish it? Kind of how do you structure it?

Shade Whitesel: I'll give a couple of examples of what they can do. They can use behaviors their dog already knows or they can pick new ones. But it's really more about we can, for instance, 'go to a bed' behavior, we can lure that, we can shape that, we can capture that so it's not so much about having behaviors already for your dog, but about explaining the different ways of getting there. It's good if your dog has some behaviors already on cue; so they can be experienced dogs, where the handler just wants to learn more about it, or it can be a dog that's brand new to stuff.

Melissa Breau: So, when you're working with your own dogs how do you decide which technique to use? I assume you're probably better with all of them than say me.

Shade Whitesel: Well, it's a steep learning curve for everything.

Melissa Breau: But how do you decide whether you want to lure something or shape something, or capture something? Like, how do you pick which method to use when you're teaching something?

Shade Whitesel: Well, I have to say when I first started training I was a big lurer and I came late to shaping. I really had no idea and my evolution in my last, I don't know, six, seven years has been really getting better at shaping. I'd be the first to say I'm not the greatest at it, but I'm getting better. So, for my own dogs shaping and capturing shaped behaviors, like, the dog offering a completed shaped behavior that's my preferred technique at this point.

If I can communicate to the dog effectively through shaping and then they can choose the behavior, I'll always teach that way first. I think it creates stronger and then more confident and faster behaviors out of the dog.

But I can't always figure out how to communicate via shaping. And so, if I can't figure that out I'll lure the behavior. I have no issue luring, but I'll then always put it on what I call capturing. And so, even if it's a lured behavior, I'll eventually want to have the dog offer it and then it becomes a strong shaped behavior, so to speak.

Melissa Breau: So, to round things out. I have three more short questions that I've asked everyone so far at the tail end of the interview. So, first what's the dog-related accomplishment that you are proudest of?

Shade Whitesel: That's such a hard one because every single dog I have had there are accomplishments that I'm really proud of with the individual dog. So, I don't think of it so much as what I've done, but more of what me and dog have done. [I Recently competed with Ones]. Schutzhund is tracking, obedience and protection and you get 100 in each. And he got 99 out of 100 in the tracking phase, he got 95 out of 100 in obedience and he got 96 out of 100 in protection. And that's a pretty good score for a young dog, because in the one and the two in Schutzhund we're kind of just seeing what does he know, how is my training going and you kind of get your three. And then, if you want to compete, you compete nationally and that's where you start to get your good scores. So, I'm excited for what the future holds for us.

Melissa Breau: So, what is the best piece of training advice that you have ever heard?

Shade Whitesel: It sounds cliché, but listen to the dog. I'm so into listening to what the dog says at this point. It holds me accountable in my training, it holds me accountable in their reinforcement and I feel like many people say, "Listen to the dog," but I think we could be doing a lot more of it.

Melissa Breau: And the last one. So, who is someone else in the dog world that you look up too?

Shade Whitesel: That's always such a hard question as well. I've been training dogs for 20 years and there's too many to name. I've learned so many things from each and every trainer, and person that I've encountered and trained with. So, I've just learned from so many people and I look up to each and every one of them.

Melissa Breau: All right. Well, thanks Shade so much for joining me.

Shade Whitesel: Yeah. Thanks so much.

Melissa Breau: And for those listening, thank you for tuning in. As a heads-up to those of you who aren't currently part of the FDSA community, registration is currently open when this airs for February classes, including Shade's Crucial Concepts for Competition Class, the one we talked about during the podcast.

And in two weeks we'll be back with Loretta Mueller to talk about why one size does not fit all when it comes to dog training.

If you haven't already, subscribe now on iTunes or the podcast app of your choice to have our next episode automatically downloaded to your phone as soon as it becomes available.

CREDITS:

Today's show is brought to you by the Fenzi Dog Sports Academy. Special thanks to Denise Fenzi for supporting this podcast. Music provided royalty-free by BenSound.com; the track featured here is called "Buddy." Audio editing provided by Chris Lang and transcription written by CLK Transcription Services.

Thanks again for tuning in -- and happy training!