
In Bed With The Right Episode 108 -- Live from San Francisco, It's Moral Panic Bingo Night!
Nov 25, 2025
Joined by cultural commentators Matt Bernstein and Sarah Marshall, the discussion dives into the world of moral panics. Matt details how AIDS panic perpetuated homophobia and shaped policy, while Sarah shares historical fears, like the windshield pitting myth from 1954. They explore themes like nostalgia, misinformation, and urban myths, such as the Halloween poisoning scare. The conversation wraps up with strategies for empathy and statistical literacy to counteract vulnerability to panics, making for a lively and insightful exchange.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Seattle Windshield Pitting Panic
- Sarah Marshall recounts the 1954 Seattle 'windshield pitting' panic where increased reporting made people suddenly notice minor flaws.
- Police concluded it was mostly hysteria, not coordinated vandalism, and the panic faded.
The Video Nasties Moral Panic
- Adrian Daub explains Britain's 'video nasties' panic tied to VHS and moral outrage over imported films.
- The murder of James Bulger reignited fears despite no real link between the killers and the disputed films.
Top-Down Fentanyl Misinformation
- The 'cops contact high' fentanyl panic was top-down misinformation from federal agencies and officials.
- Clinicians rapidly debunked it as physiologically implausible, but the narrative persisted for policing theater.








