Current Affairs

“Progress” Is Making Things Worse (w/ Sam Miller McDonald)

May 5, 2026
Sam Miller McDonald, writer and author of Progress: How One Idea Built Civilization—and Now Threatens to Destroy It, challenges the triumphalist story of progress. He questions industrial growth, ecological collapse, and how progress rhetoric has justified violence and colonialism. Conversations probe wellbeing beyond metrics and imagine alternatives to growth-driven modernization.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Prehistory Is Omitted From Progress Narratives

  • The standard progress narrative erases 98% of human history by focusing on recorded civilization and treats prehistoric peoples as uniformly warlike.
  • Sam Miller McDonald cites archaeological evidence showing systemic warfare only emerges ~5,000 years ago and prehistoric societies often had high wellbeing proxies like stature and long oral histories.
INSIGHT

Gross Progress Hides Net Harms

  • Measuring only gross progress (like tech or GDP) hides net harms such as pollution, habitat loss, and novel existential risks created by industrial civilization.
  • Miller McDonald lists cities as pollution centers, new diseases, and technologies (nukes, climate, AI risks) that didn't exist before industrialization.
INSIGHT

Ecological Collapse Puts Progress on a Hard Ceiling

  • Climate change and rapid biodiversity loss create a hard limit on the continuation of the growth-focused Western lineage of civilization.
  • He warns the current warming is faster than the Permian extinction, giving species far less time to adapt and risking a far worse die-off.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app