Total Soccer Show: USMNT, Champions League, EPL, and more ... Which league has the best Best XI of the last 25 years, when do lineups lock prior to kickoff, and more!| Listener Questions
Jan 17, 2026
Debate heats up over the USMNT's best tactical setup: should it be a double-10 formation or a two-striker approach? The panel dives into which of Europe’s top leagues features the strongest best XI from the last 25 years. A fun twist awaits as they envision a time-travel World Cup, picking legendary players to bring back in their prime. The discussion also covers the rules around lineup changes before kickoff and concludes with imaginative ideas for a goofy soccer-themed TV show featuring iconic personalities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Pulisic + Balogun Make Sense
- The USMNT should likely play a Pulisic–Balogun front two rather than a double-10 of Aaronson and McKennie.
- The front two fits current player roles and McKennie can tuck into a three-man midfield to cover balance.
La Liga Wins The 25-Year Best XI
- La Liga is judged best for a 25-year best XI because of sustained world-class players at Real Madrid and Barcelona.
- The concentration of Messi, Ronaldo, Xavi, Iniesta and top fullbacks makes Spain dominant on paper.
Why League Structure Shapes Best XIs
- Leagues' top-team concentration affects all-time XI strength; Barcelona and Real Madrid skew La Liga upward.
- The Premier League's broader competitiveness creates many great players but not the same concentrated peak.