Lost Hills: Dark Canyon

Episode 8: The Finish Line from Valley of Shadows

13 snips
Mar 2, 2026
Two retired detectives reunite to reexamine tangled leads around the AJay investigation. A suspicious double death at a deputy's home raises questions about ruled suicides and possible cover ups. Paging patterns, autopsy contradictions, and gunshot residue details are scrutinized. Investigators discuss legal strategies, oversight failures, and a troubling pattern of deaths linked to one deputy.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Case Became An Emotional Loop

  • The Ajay case became a recursive obsession that consumed reporters and retired detectives, repeating like a loop without resolution.
  • Haley Fox and Betsy Shepard compare it to Sisyphus and racing the Devil's Punchbowl with no finish line, capturing the emotional toll and persistent uncertainty.
ANECDOTE

Detectives Reunite And Reopen Leads

  • Larry Brandenburg and Darren Hager rekindled their friendship and immediately dove back into reviewing Ajay case evidence together.
  • They swapped memories about the Buffalo venture and transitioned into analyzing meth labs, informants, and suspects like Tom Hinkle and Rick Engels.
INSIGHT

Unidentified Pager Could Be A Key Clue

  • Phone records from Operation Silent Thunder showed Deputy Engels and Tom Hinkle paging the same number repeatedly after Ajay disappeared.
  • That pager number was never identified and may be a lost clue that could have linked deputies to dealers.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app