New Books in East Asian Studies Christopher Munn, "Penalties of Empire: Capital Trials in Colonial Hong Kong" (Hong Kong UP, 2025)
Mar 17, 2026
Christopher Munn, historian and former Hong Kong administrative officer, probes capital trials under British rule. He discusses landmark cases from piracy to poisonings. He explores language barriers, racialized legal categories, gendered courtroom attitudes, public pressure on clemency, and how capital punishment shaped colonial governance and reform.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Procedural Safeguards As The Cost Of Empire
- Colonial officials saw procedural safeguards as part of the cost of applying English justice overseas.
- Christopher Munn cites a 1909 Chief Justice who said "if we're going to hang people, we have to have proper procedures," framing that as a penalty of empire.
1857 Bread Poisoning Trial And An Acquittal
- In 1857 Europeans in Hong Kong feared an arsenic poisoning plot against the bread supply after the Second Opium War.
- A baker and his men were tried for poisoning but acquitted because prosecution evidence was weak and the defendants were likely innocent.
Dialect Diversity Made Interpretation Fragile
- Language barriers and many Chinese dialects made courtroom interpretation essential and error-prone in early Hong Kong.
- Munn notes interpreters were underpaid and inadequate, sometimes forcing judges to 'guess' witness meanings.
