Conversations with Tyler Henry Oliver on Measure for Measure, Late Bloomers, and the Smartest Writers in English
Henry Oliver, literary critic and author of Second Act, explores Shakespeare's Measure for Measure and its tangled moral politics. He traces links across English letters, praises Swift’s practical intelligence, and explains why many ads fail. They also debate late blooming, Austen’s debt to Adam Smith, and which works in English are over- and underrated.
59:07
Measure for Measure As A Test Of Mercy
- Measure for Measure tests whether mercy can be institutionalized rather than freely given.
- Henry Oliver links it to The Merchant of Venice: mercy is strained into a tool of government and individuals fail to live consistently by their principles.
Isabella's Agency Lost Under Moral Law
- The play can be read as feminist or at least sharply gendered because Isabella suffers the worst outcomes under the moral scheme.
- Tyler Cowen emphasizes Isabella's loss of agency—blocked convent life, threatened brother, and the Duke's coercive proposal.
Shakespeare's Pragmatism Over Idealism
- The play is pragmatist rather than idealist, choosing artifice to avert worse outcomes like death.
- Oliver argues Shakespeare prefers imperfect social solutions (marriage, substitution) over the catastrophic alternative exemplified by The Rape of Lucrece.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right 15 chevron_right 16 chevron_right 17 chevron_right 18 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 1min
Why Measure for Measure fell out of favor
01:12 • 2min
What the play is about: mercy and hypocrisy
02:50 • 3min
Feminist and pragmatic readings of Isabella's fate
05:51 • 6min
Erotic politics: Lucrece, substitutions, and rape
11:27 • 4min
Isabella's virtue and the 'I did yield to him' line
15:50 • 5min
Connections to James I and courtly context
20:21 • 2min
The Duke and Isabella as mirrors
22:41 • 2min
Religion, Catholicism, and Girardian readings
24:30 • 5min
Reading versus performance of Shakespeare
29:18 • 3min
Jane Austen, Adam Smith, and narrative perspective
32:26 • 2min
How fiction changes beliefs and Swift's practical intelligence
34:42 • 5min
Advertising insights from a literary lens
39:34 • 5min
Underrated and overrated works in English
44:41 • 3min
Late bloomers: causes and examples
48:00 • 6min
Future fiction, religion, and enjoyment of late success
53:58 • 3min
Practical advice and parting reading suggestions
57:06 • 2min
Outro
58:39 • 24sec
#98820
The journal to Stella
Letters to Esther Johnson and Rebecca Dingley, 1710–1713
Jonathan Swift
George Atherton Aitken
Esther Johnson
The Journal to Stella comprises 65 letters from Jonathan Swift to his close friend Esther Johnson, affectionately called Stella, and her companion Rebecca Dingley, covering the years 1710-1713.
These letters blend political commentary on Tory figures like Harley and St. John, personal reflections, daily life in London, and tender exchanges in Swift's 'little language' of affection.
They reveal Swift's deep emotional bond with Stella, his loneliness amid political excitement, and vivid insights into early 18th-century society.
#100645
Tale of a Tub
A Tale of a Tub
Jonathan Swift
A Tale of a Tub is a prose satire by Jonathan Swift that alternates between an allegory of three brothers—Peter (Catholic Church), Martin (Anglican Church), and Jack (Puritan dissenters)—who inherit coats from their father with instructions not to alter them, yet progressively add fashionable decorations representing corruption of original Christianity.
Interspersed with digressions criticizing modern authors, critics, and religious divisions, the work uses the brothers' quarrels and Peter's tyranny to mock religious infighting, extremism, and the misinterpretation of scripture.
Swift defends the Church of England through Martin's moderation while attacking extremes on both Catholic and dissenting sides.
#81990
The Forsyte saga
John Galsworthy
#855
• Mentioned in 42 episodes
Mansfield Park
Jane Austen
monica arcija
The novel follows Fanny Price, a young girl from a poor family who is sent to live with her wealthy uncle and aunt, Sir Thomas and Lady Bertram, at Mansfield Park.
Fanny navigates the complexities of her new environment, dealing with the mistreatment by some family members and the kindness of her cousin Edmund.
The story unfolds with the arrival of the charming but morally dubious Crawfords, leading to a series of scandals and moral dilemmas.
Ultimately, Fanny's integrity and compassion guide her through the challenges, and she finds love and a sense of belonging with Edmund.
#27556
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
The Drapier's Letters
Jonathan Swift
#6645
• Mentioned in 7 episodes
Democracy
Joan Didion
Set in Hawaii and Southeast Asia at the end of the Vietnam War, 'Democracy' follows Inez Christian Victor, the wife of Senator Harry Victor, and her complex relationship with Jack Lovett, a CIA agent and war profiteer.
The novel delves into themes of American politics, public and private life, the media, and image management.
It is narrated by Joan Didion, who presents herself as an acquaintance of Inez, adding a layer of personal and reflective storytelling.
The book is characterized by its fragmented structure, reflecting the anxiety and sense of helplessness of the modern age, and it critiques the superficiality of liberal politics and the disillusionment of contemporary life.
#2036
• Mentioned in 22 episodes
Merchant of Venice
William Shakespeare
The play revolves around Antonio, a wealthy merchant of Venice, who takes a loan from the Jewish moneylender Shylock to help his friend Bassanio woo the wealthy heiress Portia.
When Antonio's ships are reported lost at sea, he is unable to repay the loan, and Shylock demands his pound of flesh as per the bond.
The play culminates in a trial where Portia, disguised as a lawyer, intervenes to save Antonio's life.
The play explores themes of debt, mercy, and the complexities of human relationships in 16th-century Venice.
#6
• Mentioned in 538 episodes
The Lord of the Rings
J.R.R Tolkien
The Lord of the Rings, written by J.R. R.
Tolkien, is an epic high fantasy novel set in Middle-earth.
The story follows Frodo Baggins, a hobbit who inherits the One Ring from his uncle Bilbo.
The Ring, forged by Sauron, holds the power to control all other Rings of Power and must be destroyed in the fires of Mount Doom to prevent Sauron's return.
Frodo is joined by a fellowship of other characters, including Gandalf the Grey, Samwise Gamgee, Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, and Boromir, as they embark on a dangerous quest across Middle-earth.
The novel explores themes of good vs.
evil, the corrupting influence of power, and the struggle between fate and free will.
#813
• Mentioned in 43 episodes
Bleak House
Charles Dickens
Bleak House, published in 1852-1853, is a novel by Charles Dickens that revolves around the Jarndyce family and their entanglement in the interminable lawsuit of Jarndyce and Jarndyce.
The story highlights the inefficiencies and injustices of the English Court of Chancery, as well as themes of family secrets, blackmail, murder, and social critique.
The novel follows Esther Summerson, who becomes the guardian of two other wards, Richard Carstone and Ada Clare, and their lives as they navigate the complexities of the lawsuit and personal secrets, particularly those surrounding Lady Dedlock and her past.
The novel is known for its vivid portrayal of Victorian England and its critique of various social and legal institutions of the time.
#100
• Mentioned in 169 episodes
Paradise Lost
John Milton
Published in 1667, 'Paradise Lost' is an epic poem in blank verse that follows the biblical story of the Fall of Man. The poem begins in medias res, detailing the descent of Satan and his followers into Hell after their rebellion against God. It explores two main narrative arcs: one focusing on Satan's actions and the other on Adam and Eve's story in the Garden of Eden.
The poem delves into themes such as free will, obedience, revenge, and pride, and it portrays the complex characters of Satan, Adam, and Eve. Milton's work is known for its rich language, classical structure, and profound theological and philosophical insights.
#24126
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
The rape of Lucrece
William Shakespeare
The Rape of Lucrece is a narrative poem that tells the tragic story of Lucrece, a virtuous Roman noblewoman.
She is raped by Tarquin, the son of the king, leading to her public confession and suicide.
The poem explores themes of honor, virtue, and the devastating consequences of sexual violence and betrayal.
Shakespeare delves into the psychological impact of the assault on Lucrece, portraying her internal struggles and moral anguish.
The poem also examines the political ramifications of Tarquin's crime, which ultimately leads to the overthrow of the Roman monarchy and the establishment of the Roman Republic.
#45
• Mentioned in 257 episodes
Atlas Shrugged
Ayn Rand
Published in 1957, 'Atlas Shrugged' is Ayn Rand's magnum opus and her longest novel.
The story is set in a dystopian United States where increasingly burdensome laws and regulations strangle innovation and productivity.
The plot follows Dagny Taggart, a railroad executive, and Hank Rearden, a steel magnate, as they struggle against 'looters' who exploit their work.
A mysterious figure named John Galt leads a strike of productive individuals, persuading them to abandon their companies and disappear.
The novel culminates with Galt's three-hour radio speech explaining his philosophy of Objectivism, which emphasizes rational self-interest, individual rights, and the importance of the human mind.
The book explores themes of capitalism, property rights, and the failures of governmental coercion, presenting a provocative vision of a society in collapse and the potential for a new capitalist society based on Galt's principles.
#5334
• Mentioned in 9 episodes
The faerie queene
Edmund Spenser
Edmund Spenser's "The Faerie Queene" is an epic poem that allegorically explores the virtues and vices of human nature.
Through its intricate narrative and rich symbolism, the poem celebrates the ideals of chivalry, piety, and justice.
The poem's characters and events are often interpreted as representing abstract concepts and moral lessons.
Its complex structure and allegorical depth have made it a subject of ongoing scholarly debate.
Its enduring influence on English literature is undeniable, shaping the development of epic poetry and allegorical writing.
#736
• Mentioned in 46 episodes
Gulliver's travels
Jonathan Swift
Jonathan Swift's "Gulliver's Travels" is a satirical masterpiece that uses fantastical journeys to critique human nature and societal flaws.
Gulliver's encounters with Lilliputians, Brobdingnagians, and other fantastical creatures serve as allegories for political and social issues of Swift's time.
The novel's sharp wit and biting satire continue to resonate with readers today, offering a timeless commentary on human folly and the complexities of power.
Gulliver's experiences highlight the absurdity of human conflict and the importance of reason and moderation.
The book's enduring popularity stems from its ability to entertain while simultaneously provoking thought and challenging readers' assumptions.
#10648
• Mentioned in 5 episodes
Measure for Measure
William Shakespeare
Measure for Measure is a play that centers on the fate of Claudio, who is arrested by Lord Angelo for impregnating his fiancée before marriage.
The play explores themes of justice, morality, and deception as the Duke of Vienna, disguised as a friar, intervenes to resolve the crisis.
It is often classified as a 'problem play' due to its complex moral questions and dark comedic elements.
Sign up for the Chicago CWT Listener Meetup.
Henry Oliver is the preeminent literary critic for non-literary nerds. His Substack, The Common Reader, has thousands of subscribers drawn in by Henry's conviction that great literature is where ideas "walk and talk amongst the mess of the real world" in a way no other discipline can match. Tyler, who has called Henry's book Second Act "one of the very best books written on talent," sat down with him to compare readings of Measure for Measure and range across English literature more broadly.
Tyler and Henry trade rival readings of the play, debate whether Isabella secretly seduces Angelo, argue over whether the Duke's proposal is closer to liberation or enslavement, trace the play's connections to The Merchant of Venice and The Rape of Lucrece, assess the parallels to James I, weigh whether it's a Girardian play (Oliver: emphatically not), and parse exactly what Isabella means when she says "I did yield to him," before turning to the best way to consume Shakespeare, what Jane Austen took from Adam Smith, why Swift may be the most practically intelligent writer in English, how advertising really works and why most of it doesn't, which works in English literature are under- and overrated, what makes someone a late bloomer, whether fiction will deal seriously with religion again, whether Ayn Rand's villains are more relevant now than ever, and much more.
Read a full transcript enhanced with helpful links, or watch the full video on the new dedicated Conversations with Tyler channel.
Recorded January 12th, 2026.
This episode was made possible through the support of the John Templeton Foundation.
Other ways to connect
- Follow us on X and Instagram
- Follow Tyler on X
- Follow Henry on X
- Sign up for our newsletter
- Join our Discord
- Email us: cowenconvos@mercatus.gmu.edu
- Learn more about Conversations with Tyler and other Mercatus Center podcasts here.
Timestamps:
00:00:00 - Intro
00:01:40 - What Shakespeare is really saying in Measure for Measure
00:29:17 - The best way to consume Shakespeare
00:32:26 - Jane Austen, Adam Smith, and Jonathan Swift
00:39:29 - Advertising that works
00:44:37 - Things that are under- and overrated in literature
00:51:24 - Late bloomers
00:58:36 - Outro
Image Credit: Sam Alburger