
The Prancing Pony Podcast 095 - They Say It's Your Birthday
Sep 23, 2018
Sherat Bhutavarapu, a graduate student and Tolkien enthusiast, shares how he found Tolkien and what drew him in. He talks about favorite works like The Silmarillion and Smith of Wootton Major. Short takes include counting in Old English, Bilbo’s eleventy-first quirks, hobbit family gossip, and Tolkien’s stubbornness with proofreaders.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Eleventy First Derives From Old English Counting
- Tolkien's eleventy-first phrasing echoes an Old English long-hundred counting system rather than pure whimsy.
- Shawn references Ring of Words and explains medieval base-12 "long hundred" forms like hundenleventig that inform Tolkien's 111st choice.
Bilbo's Party Underwent Major Early Rewrites
- Early drafts show Tolkien repeatedly revised Bilbo's party plan and family relations across four versions.
- Alan and Shawn outline versions where Bilbo disappears at 111, sometimes has a son Bingo, or adopts Frodo, showing the story's evolving focus.
Sackville-Baggins Ambition Comes Through Maternal Inheritance
- Tolkien's letter 214 reveals Otho Sackville-Baggins inherited his nominal headship through his mother, Camellia.
- Shawn reads Tolkien calling Otho's ambition "rather absurd" to be head of two families, explaining Sackville-Baggins resentment.







