
New Books in Science, Technology, and Society Agnes Arnold-Forster, "The Cancer Problem: Malignancy in Nineteenth-Century Britain" (Oxford UP, 2021)
Aug 25, 2025
Agnes Arnold-Forster, a historian of medicine and emotions at McGill University, explores the complex history of cancer in 19th-century Britain. She discusses the groundbreaking acceptance of terminal cancer patients at the Middlesex Hospital and the evolving dynamics between male doctors and female patients. Arnold-Forster highlights the emergence of cancer mapping in rural areas, countering popular beliefs about urban disease hotspots. She also delves into societal fears and the shifting medical understandings that still resonate today.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Quackery As Contested Label
- 'Quack' was socially constructed and used by orthodox journals to delegitimize rivals, even credentialed practitioners.
- Claims of cures often defined someone as a quack regardless of other markers of orthodoxy.
Incurability Redefined Cancer Identity
- Because incurability was tied to the disease identity, claimed cures led critics to argue the original diagnosis was wrong.
- This circular logic made proven cures socially and medically controversial.
Mapping Cancer To Rural Affluence
- Haviland's maps linked cancer to rural, picturesque British regions, making cancer a paradoxical sign of affluence.
- This association reframed cancer as tied to progress and modernity rather than only to urban squalor.

