The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Who should be the MVP, What's going on in GB, Belichick to the Giants?
Nov 12, 2025
NFL MVP discussions heat up as various candidates are evaluated, with a special focus on Drake Maye. Green Bay's coaching challenges come under scrutiny, questioning playcalling and personnel fit. A look into the potential hiring landscape reveals debates over Bill Belichick's future and those who may replace Sean McDermott. The Eagles' playoff prospects are examined, alongside the frustrations of Packers and Steelers fans as they face roster issues.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Owners Aren't The Primary On-Field Factor
- John says new Colts owner presence likely doesn't drive on-field success; quarterback play does.
- He argues ownership involvement matters less than roster and coaching quality.
Coaches Are Rarely Traded
- Coaches rarely get traded because teams usually refuse to let high-value coaches leave.
- Trades like Gruden or Payton were exceptional circumstances, not common practice.
Think Twice Before Midlevel Coach Firings
- John warns against firing successful NFL coaches without a clear, superior replacement available.
- He expects next offseason's coaching market to offer fewer attractive, proven NFL candidates.