The Commentary Magazine Podcast

No, No, Noem

32 snips
Jan 26, 2026
They analyze the chaotic Minneapolis shooting response and the rush to politicize early claims. They debate calls to remove a prominent official over public statements and examine video ambiguity. They critique hardline immigration messaging and its political costs. They discuss Israel’s returned hostage and how that shifts military options. They cover Iran’s brutal domestic crackdown and Washington’s agonizing strategic choices.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Cost Of Premature Official Claims

  • The administration's immediate, unverified statements about Alex Preddy's shooting worsened tensions and eroded trust.
  • John Podhoretz argues officials should have paused, promised investigations, and avoided slandering the deceased.
ADVICE

Cut Toxic Surrogates Fast

  • Remove Kristi Noem from public-facing roles to reduce inflammatory rhetoric and restore credibility.
  • John Podhoretz recommends the Trump administration offload Noem and keep incendiary surrogates from speaking.
INSIGHT

Zealotry Drives Counterproductive Policy

  • Stephen Miller's influence fuels uncompromising immigration tactics that escalate political and PR risk.
  • Panelists say Miller frames backing down as existential, pressuring Trump to double down despite optics problems.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app