Dateline NBC The Last Appeal - Ep. 3: A Date to Die
11 snips
Oct 11, 2025 Brian Wharton, a former detective turned United Methodist minister, shares his deep-seated doubts about the investigation that led to Robert Roberson's death row conviction. He discusses the troubling implications of a discredited shaken baby syndrome theory and the failure to properly account for Roberson's autism. Excitingly, missing CAT scans found in a courthouse basement contradict crucial autopsy findings. Wharton expresses remorse over investigative failings and vows to help Robert, weaving a tale of justice, faith, and second chances.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Allegation Damage Outlasts Charges
- Allegations of sexual assault were repeatedly mentioned at trial despite no corroborating DNA or medical evidence.
- Gretchen argues those allegations poisoned the jury even after prosecutors dropped the charge.
Discredited Science Undermined Conviction
- Gretchen showed that shaken baby science had collapsed since Robert's trial, undermining the prosecution's core theory.
- Removing shaken baby claims, she says, collapses the state's case against Robert.
Autism Explains Demeanor
- Brian realized Robert's autism diagnosis explained his demeanor and that investigators had not listened to him.
- He admitted they failed to hear or investigate Robert's account at the time.