The Morning Edition The Sketch: Tony Wright on 'Nation's worst government? Jane Hume's hyperbolic historical claim'
Feb 19, 2026
Tony Wright, associate editor at The Age and 50-year political sketch veteran, riffs on Jane Hume’s claim that Labor is the nation’s worst government. He compares recent Coalition leaders, revisits McMahon and Whitlam’s chaotic years, recalls Billy Hughes’ party hopping and Scullin’s Depression-era woes. A witty tour of notorious political moments that asks: who really deserves the crown?
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Hyperbole Versus Historical Perspective
- Tony Wright argues Jane Hume's claim that Labor is "the worst government in this nation's history" is hyperbolic and provokes historical comparison.
- He shows many past governments present stronger cases, revealing the subjectivity of "worst" judgments.
Recent Governments As Contenders
- Wright notes Jane Hume served as a minister under Scott Morrison, reminding listeners of her part in a recent government.
- He then recounts the chaotic Abbott and Rudd-Gillard periods as contenders for 'worst'.
McMahon And Whitlam Episodes
- Wright recalls Billy McMahon's fumbling prime ministership, including his joke about having "nothing about the future".
- He contrasts with Whitlam's achievements and the chaotic final year involving secret loan attempts.