That's So Criminal Finding Nancy Episode: Don't Stop Believing - Ep. 16
Feb 25, 2026
A family offers a $1 million reward as a desperate plea for help. Investigators debate whether porch photos were taken on different nights, suggesting prior visits or multiple people. Partial DNA from the home proved inconclusive. Authorities also probe a separate elderly burial, raising fears of a possible pattern and wider threat.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Guthrie Family Announces $1 Million Reward
- Savannah Guthrie publicly offered a $1 million family reward for information leading to her mother Nancy's recovery.
- Lyndon Blake highlighted the family's emotional plea and Savannah's admission they suspect Nancy may be dead while still hoping for a miracle.
Timing Of Reward Raises Questions
- Lyndon Blake questioned why the reward wasn't offered earlier and reported conflicting accounts about whether law enforcement advised the family to delay the reward.
- NBC said police advised against a reward to avoid overwhelming unstructured tips, but Blake's sources said investigators wouldn't tell a family to withhold money.
Guthries Donate To Missing Children Center
- The Guthrie family pledged $500,000 to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children amid their own crisis.
- Blake framed this as a generous move showing awareness that many families face similar pain and need support.