The McShay Show Mock Draft 3.0! Love’s Market, Simpson’s Fall, and More Round 1 Takeaways.
Mar 23, 2026
Steve Muench, experienced NFL talent evaluator and draft analyst, joins to break down Mock Draft 3.0. They debate Jeremiah Love’s top billing and whether the Giants should take him. They dig into Ty Simpson’s market, landing spots, and comparison to past quarterbacks. Quick rundowns cover surprising top-five choices, key fits for teams like the Chiefs, and late-first/second-round sleepers.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Jeremiah Love Could Go Top Five
- Jeremiah Love is being evaluated as a top-two talent despite being a running back because teams value his playmaking and pass-catching fit for mobile quarterbacks.
- Todd McShay points to organizational fits like the Giants and John Harbaugh-style builds where Love's skill set complements a mobile QB and a heavy commitment to the run game.
McShay Draft Room Aims To Mirror NFL Draft Tools
- McShay and Steve launched the McShay Draft Room to mirror NFL front-office tools with top-100 boards, scouting reports, and filters for team needs.
- The site emphasizes position-specific scouting, spider charts, and continuous expansion toward a top-350-style database.
Ty Simpson Is High-Reward But High-Risk
- Ty Simpson is polarizing: his tape draws quarterback evaluators but his limited starts and injury history create real draft risk.
- Steve Muench and Todd McShay compare him to past one-year college starters and suggest he may be better valued late first/early second to manage expectations.