Exploring Mormon Thought 029-The Implausibility of Original Sin - The Problems of Theism & The Love of God Ch 4
Nov 6, 2017
Dive into the intriguing debate on original sin, where traditional Christian views clash with unique Mormon interpretations. Explore Augustine's influence and the concept of corporate guilt, questioning whether we can truly be held accountable for another's actions. Delve into the fairness of Adam’s guilt impacting all humanity and the moral responsibilities we bear in extreme dilemmas. The discussion also unveils how moral choices are tested in life-and-death situations, providing thought-provoking perspectives on ethics and individual agency.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Pelagian Denial of Original Sin
- Pelagianism denies original sin entirely, claiming we'd never sin if we had sufficient moral strength.
- It holds that sinfulness is not inevitable and all sin is from personal choice.
Anselmianism's Logical Paradox
- Anselmianism teaches Adam lost a supernatural gift enabling him to do good, but its loss causes inevitable sin.
- This raises a logical problem: If equipped to avoid sin, why did Adam sin initially?
The Problem of Vicarious Guilt
- The core problem of original sin is how one person can be morally guilty for another's act.
- Personal moral responsibility traditionally requires free choice, which contradicts inherited guilt.
