48 Hours

The Case Against Sandra Garner

14 snips
Mar 26, 2026
Sandra Garner, a woman who testified about her husband being shot, shares her first-person account and the 911 call. The story covers the missing gun found in her locked car, suspicious web searches on her devices, interrogation and a long pretrial jail stay. It also explores investigative mistakes, questions about her son, the courtroom drama and her eventual not guilty verdict and release.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Sandra's Firsthand Account Of The Intruder

  • Sandra Garner told police she woke to two gunshots, saw a masked white male with a flashlight and gun, and was told to count to 100 before calling 911.
  • She described handing a lockbox with about $18,000 to the intruder who claimed John ruined his life, then making the 911 call.
INSIGHT

Missing Revolver Appeared In Her Car

  • Investigators found one missing .38 revolver belonged to Sandra and recovered it wrapped in wet towels under the Mustang's front seat three days later.
  • Ballistics matched that .38 to John's fatal shot, but the weapon had no fingerprints or DNA and appeared after initial searches.
INSIGHT

Controversial Google Searches On Her Devices

  • Sandra's electronics showed searches like "16 ways to kill somebody and not get caught" days before the murder, which prosecutors used to build motive.
  • Defense argued devices were accessible to others and Sandra had health struggles, complicating intent conclusions.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app