The Jimmy Akin Podcast #059 Did Jesus Rise from the Dead? DEBATE! - Jimmy Akin
Nov 11, 2025
In a lively debate, Jimmy Akin, a senior apologist at Catholic Answers, defends the assertion that Jesus rose from the dead against skeptic James Fodor, a neuroscientist and author. They delve into compelling subjects like the empty tomb, eyewitness fallibility, and the RHBS model of hallucinations. Jimmy argues the resurrection hypothesis elegantly explains the post-crucifixion facts, while James counters with alternative theories and insights on social processes behind miracles. Their exchange is a captivating intellectual sparring match on faith and reason.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Memory Reshapes Reports Over Time
- Fodor highlights memory's reconstructive nature and how retelling reshapes accounts toward coherence.
- He cites studies where social exposure greatly increases adoption of false memories.
Who Carries The Burden Of Proof
- Jimmy Akin insists the burden of proof lies with whoever asks others to change belief.
- He advises challengers to provide reasons rather than assuming opponents must disprove claims.
Three Priors On The Paranormal
- Akin frames three worldviews on paranormal events: skeptical materialism, evangelical restraint, and early Christian openness.
- These priors predict how one will weigh resurrection claims.
