Quillette Podcast The Freedom to Blaspheme
Jul 17, 2024
Jonathan Kay talks to Kushal Mehra about the similarities in censorship campaigns in India and Canada, discussing the impact of laws like the Herms Act and Section 295A on free speech. They delve into Canada's Online Harm Act, exploring the harsh penalties for hate speech and concerns about selective application of laws. The conversation also touches on blasphemy laws in different countries, the distorted perceptions of danger fueled by media exposure, and the influence of national core cohesiveness on free speech in diverse societies.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Online Harm Act Combines Good And Dangerous Provisions
- Bill C-63 mixes sensible online-safety measures with vague, dangerous speech restrictions that expand government power.
- The bill could criminalize broad political speech and impose life sentences for hate speech under an expanded definition.
Vague Harmony Standards Invite Abuse
- Laws that protect 'harmony' and 'tranquility' are highly subjective and easily weaponized.
- Such vagueness invites selective enforcement against unpopular groups or dissenting views.
Think Beyond Today's Ruling Party
- Never give the state powers you wouldn't want your worst political enemy to wield in future administrations.
- Consider how laws will be applied beyond today's political moment before supporting them.