
The Prancing Pony Podcast 093 - We're In the Same Tale Still!
12 snips
Sep 9, 2018 They trace the seventeen-year journey from The Hobbit to The Lord of the Rings, including publication twists and publisher negotiations. They explore Tolkien’s writing phases, lost time during war, and how characters and plot elements like the Ring and Faramir evolved. They recount Tolkien’s 1958 Rotterdam hobbit dinner speech and recommend key reference works for deeper reading.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Tolkien At The Rotterdam Hobbit Dinner
- At a 1958 hobbit-themed dinner in Rotterdam, J.R.R. Tolkien gave a playful speech and toasted "To the Hobbits."
- He joked about maggot soup (actually mushroom soup) and noted hobbits have no magic weapons but may outlast Saruman's descendants.
Tolkien Preferred The Silmarillion Over A Sequel
- After The Hobbit's success Tolkien resisted writing a direct sequel and instead wanted to publish his deeper mythology, the Silmarillion.
- He told publishers he had "only too much to say" about the wider world but little more to say about hobbits themselves.
Lord Of The Rings Grew Through Layered Rewrites
- Christopher Tolkien reconstructed three main early composition phases for the opening chapters, with many rewrites and shifting drafts.
- Textual elements migrated, alternative versions overlapped, and sequencing became extremely complex to untangle.




