
The Red Nation Podcast RPH. vs Smoke Signals (1998)
Mar 16, 2026
A lively look at Smoke Signals as a landmark Indigenous-made film and why it still matters. They unpack themes of grief, masculinity, and redemption through Victor and Thomas. Conversation covers Sherman Alexie’s influence and the fallout around his misconduct. Calls for more Indigenous women, Two Spirit, and queer storytellers and critique of limited female roles appear throughout.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Smoke Signals' Cultural Breakthrough
- Smoke Signals is historically significant as the first major-studio feature written, directed, and nearly entirely acted by Native people.
- Elena Ortiz and Melanie Yazzie emphasize Sherman Alexie's central role in the screenplay and its impact on Native literary-to-film crossover.
Author Legacy Complicates Film Reception
- Sherman Alexie's authorship complicates the film's legacy because of later allegations and his outsized influence mentoring Native writers.
- Melanie and Elena note his mentorship at IAIA and the 2018 misconduct revelations that reframed how people view his work.
Canon Overloaded With Male Perspectives
- The hosts critique a repeated pattern: canonical Indigenous media is dominated by men writing about men.
- They call for expansion to women, LGBTQ, and Two-Spirit creators, citing Reservation Dogs as a positive contrast.



