Catholic Answers Live #12601 Why Aren’t You Catholic? Authority, Confession, and Mary - Karlo Broussard
Feb 23, 2026
Dr. Carlo Broussard, Catholic apologist and author, brings theological clarity with sharp historical references. He explores post-apostolic authority and bishops as successors. He teases why confession still matters after baptism. He discusses Peter’s marital status and examines Mary’s immaculate conception and death. The tone is curious, precise, and deeply rooted in tradition.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Scripture Points To Continuing Infallible Authority
- 1 Timothy 3:15 implies the Church is the pillar and foundation of truth, meaning the Church must be secure in what it teaches.
- Carlo Broussard connects that scriptural claim to early testimony (Ignatius, Clement) to argue for continued infallible apostolic authority in bishops.
Baptism Forgives Yet Confession Remains Necessary
- Baptism forgives sins initially but Scripture (Our Father, 1 John 1:9) shows baptized Christians can incur guilt from post-baptismal sins.
- Carlo uses John 20:23 to explain the ordinary means of remission is the sacrament of reconciliation.
Start Conversations By Asking Honest Questions
- Ask honest, targeted questions to understand a Protestant's beliefs before arguing, like asking what they believe about salvation or church authority.
- Carlo recommended using resources (Catholic.com, articles, books) and following up by offering specific material to read and discuss.
