80,000 Hours Podcast Luisa and Keiran on free will, and the consequences of never feeling enduring guilt or shame
24 snips
Sep 27, 2024 In this engaging discussion, Keiran Harris, co-host of 80k After Hours, shares his intriguing insights on free will and the ramifications of experiencing little guilt or shame. Together with Luisa Rodriguez, they explore how these emotions shape morality and personal choices. They ponder whether reduced guilt would lead people to become worse friends or citizens. The conversation also touches on 'jerk syndrome,' the nuances of love beyond agency, and practical tips for navigating heavy emotions with compassion.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Libertarian Free Will
- Kieran believes libertarian free will, the ability to have truly chosen differently, doesn't exist.
- He equates it to believing in magic and notes its incompatibility with determinism.
Implications of Determinism
- Kieran emphasizes the implications of determinism extend beyond philosophical debates.
- It impacts personal psychology and societal structures like the criminal justice system.
Guilt and Productivity
- Kieran questions whether guilt-induced extra work is positive.
- He suggests it may lead to burnout and discourage others, making it ultimately less effective.