Most nonprofits set donation tiers like math problems: $25, $50, $100, $250. The problem? Donors see it coming—and it doesn’t inspire them to give more. In this episode of The Million Dollar Nonprofit, Tom Kelly reveals how to turn boring donation ladders into powerful invitations that move donors from “just giving” to becoming part of a story.
Using the psychology of anchoring, storytelling to align tiers with real impact, and smart automation to nudge donors upward, you’ll learn how to increase your average gift without chasing bigger lists. Tom shares practical ChatGPT prompts, real-world examples, and a 3-step framework—Anchor, Align, Automate—that nonprofits can swipe and use right away. If you’re ready to stop selling numbers and start selling meaning, this episode will show you how to transform your giving tiers into an engine for growth.
Million Dollar Nonprofit